The place of magic in the intellectual history of EuropeThorndike, Lynn
History
The place of magic in the intellectual history of Europe
Thorndike, Lynn
Magic -- Europe -- History
Marcellus of Bordeaux, court physician of Theodosius I, and a writer
upon medicine, throws some light upon the state of medicine in his day.
He affirmed that pimples might be removed by wiping them the instant you
saw a falling-star. He said that a tumor could be cured if one half of a
root of vervain were tied about the sufferer’s neck and the other half
suspended over a fire. His theory was that as the vervain dried up in
the smoke of the fire, the tumor would by force of magic sympathy
likewise dry up and disappear. Marcellus added for the benefit of unpaid
physicians that so persistent would be the sympathetic bond established
that if the root of the vervain were later thrown into water, its
absorption of moisture would produce a return of the tumor.[218]
Ammianus Marcellinus, who wrote at the close of the fourth century, and
who has been regarded by his critics from Gibbon down as a historian of
distinguished merit, gives us an idea of mental conditions in his time,
and was himself not free from belief in magic. It is true that in
declaiming against the degeneracy of the Roman aristocracy he ridicules
their trust in astrology, saying that many of them deny the existence of
higher powers in heaven, yet think it imprudent to appear in public or
dine or take a bath without first having consulted an almanac as to
Mercury’s whereabouts or the exact position of the moon in Cancer.[219]
Yet he believed in omens, portents and auspices, as the following
citations will indicate and as one might show by other passages.
The first passage is one in which Ammianus speaks of Alexandria as
formerly having been a great place of learning and as even in his
degenerate days a considerable intellectual centre. According to him, it
is a sufficient recommendation for any medical man if he say that he was
educated at Alexandria.[220]
There whatever lies hidden is laid bare by geometry; music is not
utterly forgotten nor harmony neglected; among some men, though their
number may not be great, the motion of the world and stars is still a
matter of consideration; there are not a few of those skilled in
numbers.
This is not all. “Besides these things they cherish the science which
reveals the decrees of fate.”[221]
The Emperor Julian was continually inspecting entrails of victims and
interpreting dreams and omens, and even proposed to reopen a prophetic
fountain which Hadrian was said to have blocked up for fear that others,
like himself, might win the imperial throne through obedience to its
predictions.[222] The mention of such practices of Julian leads Ammianus
in another passage to attempt a justification of divination as a science
worthy of the study and respect of the most erudite and intelligent. He
says:
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account