The Popes and Science: The History of the Papal Relations to Science During the Middle Ages and Down to Our Own TimeWalsh, James J. (James Joseph)
Religion
The Popes and Science: The History of the Papal Relations to Science During the Middle Ages and Down to Our Own Time
Walsh, James J. (James Joseph)
Popes; Religion and science -- History; Science -- History
"Thirteen years later there is an account of the dissection of two
female bodies, in January and March of the year 1315, performed by
Mundinus." (We have already seen that the fact that the two female
bodies should be especially mentioned, though taken by some
historians of medicine to indicate that Mundinus had done but few
dissections, will not stand such an interpretation, in the light of
the evidence that he had dissected many male bodies at least, as his
text-book of anatomy indeed makes very clear. These two dissections
of females happened only to have special features that made them
noteworthy.) "A few years later (1319) there is a remarkable
document which tells the story of body-snatching for dissecting
purposes." (This would seem to be sufficient of itself to show that
a number of dissections were being done, and, indeed, as I have
already said, Rashdall, in his History of the Universities, states
that, according to the University statutes teachers were bound to
dissect such bodies as students brought to them.) Roth concludes
with the words (italics are mine): "_These are a few, but weighty
testimonies for the zeal with which Bologna pursued anatomy in the
fourteenth century._" (I may add that all of these concern the
twenty years immediately following Pope Boniface's supposed
prohibition.)
Nor was the custom of making dissections any less active during the
rest of the half century after the time when, if we are to believe
Professor White, the decree of Boniface had been universally
interpreted to forbid it. In a note to his history of dissection
during this period in Bologna, Roth says: "Without doubt the passage
in {74} Guy de Chauliac which tells of having very often (multitoties,
many times, is the exact word) seen dissections must be considered as
referring to Bologna." This passage runs as follows: "My master,
Bertruccius, conducted the dissection very often after the following
manner: The dead body having been placed upon a bench, he used to make
four lessons on it. First, the nutritional portions were treated,
because they are so likely to become putrified. In the second, he
demonstrated the spiritual members; in the third, the animate members;
in the fourth, the extremities." (Guy de Chauliac was at Bologna
studying under Bertruccius just before the middle of the fourteenth
century. It is evident beyond all doubt, from what he says, that
dissections were quite common. This is during the first fifty years
after the decree. I shall show a little later that there are records
of dissections during the second half of this century. Roth, however,
goes on to tell next of the fifteenth century.)
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account