deliver my lectures, I withdrew from academic life and ceased to attend
the learned societies. It is a whole generation since I have visited the
“Gesellschaft der Aerzte.”
Anyone who wanted to make a living from the treatment of nerve-patients
must clearly be able to do something to help them. My therapeutic
arsenal contained only two weapons, electrotherapy and hypnosis, for
prescribing a visit to a hydropathic establishment after a single
consultation was an inadequate source of income. My knowledge of
electrotherapy was derived from W. Erb’s text-book, which provided
detailed instructions for the treatment of all the symptoms of nervous
diseases. Unluckily I was soon driven to see that following these
instructions was of no help whatever and that what I had taken for an
epitome of exact observations was merely the construction of phantasy.
The realization that the work of the greatest name in German
neuropathology had no more relation to reality than some “Egyptian”
dream-book, such as are sold in cheap book-shops, was painful, but it
helped to rid me of yet another piece of the innocent faith in authority
by which I was still obsessed. So I put my electrical apparatus aside,
even before Möbius had solved the problem by explaining that the
successes of electric treatment in nervous disorders (in so far as there
were any) were the effect of suggestion on the part of the physician.
With hypnosis the case was better. While I was still a student I had
attended a public exhibition given by the “magnetist” Hansen and had
noticed that one of the persons experimented upon had became deathly
pale at the onset of cataleptic rigidity and had remained so as long as
that condition lasted. This firmly convinced me of the genuineness of
the phenomena of hypnosis. Scientific support was soon afterwards given
to this view by Heidenhain; but that did not restrain the professors of
psychiatry from declaring for a long time to come that hypnosis was not
only fraudulent but dangerous and from regarding hypnotists with
contempt. In Paris I had seen hypnosis used freely as a method for
producing symptoms in patients and then removing them again. And now the
news reached us that a school had arisen at Nancy which made an
extensive and remarkably successful use of suggestion, with or without
hypnosis, for therapeutic purposes. It thus came about, as a matter of
course, that in the first years of my activity as a physician my
principal instrument of work, apart from haphazard and unsystematic
psycho-therapeutic methods, was hypnotic suggestion.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account