The Religio-Medical Masquerade: A Complete Exposure of Christian SciencePeabody, Frederick William
Religion
The Religio-Medical Masquerade: A Complete Exposure of Christian Science
Peabody, Frederick William
Christian Science -- Controversial literature
“Matter has no _intelligence_ of its own, and to believe
intelligence is in matter is the error which produces pain and
inharmony of all sorts; to hold ourselves we are a principle
outside of matter, we would not be influenced by the opinions
of man, but held to the workings only of a principle, Truth, in
which there are no inharmonies of sickness, pain, or sin.”
“For matter is an error, there being no _substance_, which is
_Truth_ in a thing which changes and is only that which belief
makes it.”
“Christ was the Wisdom that knew Truth dwelt not in opinion and
that matter was but opinion that could be formed into any shape
which the belief gave to it, and that the _life_ which moved it
came not from it, but was outside of it.”
Eddy:
“Matter is mortal error,”—Page 169, edition of 1881.
“The fundamental error of mortal man is the belief that matter
is intelligent.”—Page 122, edition of 1881.
“Laws of matter are nothing more or less than a belief of
intelligence and life in matter, which is the procuring cause
of all disease; whereas God, Truth, is its positive cure.”—Page
127, edition of 1881.
“There is no _life_, _truth_, _intelligence_, or _substance_ in
matter.”—Page 464, edition of 1898.
[It will be seen that every idea contained in this last
passage, Mrs. Eddy’s famous “scientific statement of being,”
the mental repetition of which constitutes Christian Science
“treatment,” is taken from Dr. Quimby’s writings.]
This paralleling of Eddyism, or Christian Science, with Quimbyism
shows that, as late as 1870, Mrs. Eddy professed to have learned
from Quimby, that error is sickness; that belief is sickness;
that discord is sickness; that there is no life, truth,
intelligence, or substance in matter; that matter is error; that
the belief of intelligence in matter is the cause of all disease;
that Truth is God; that there is no other truth but God; that God
is Principle; that Wisdom, Love and Truth are Principle; that
Truth is health and cures sickness; that harmony, by destroying
disharmony, cures disease; and, finally, that all disease
originates in mind and is cured by mind alone.
And this is the sum total, the beginning and the end, of that
strange thing Mrs. Eddy calls Christian Science, as it is
contained and set forth in her book, “Science and Health.”
If the founder of Christian Science could be _expected_ to give a
candid answer to a plain question, might not some such respectful
inquiry as the following at this point be pertinently propounded:
If Mrs. Patterson, or Mrs. Glover, afterwards Mrs. Eddy, in 1868,
1869 and 1870 openly avowed that the “scientific mind healing”
she then taught was the discovery of Dr. P. P. Quimby, when and
how did Mrs. Eddy, formerly Mrs. Patterson and Mrs. Glover,
discover that she had discovered it herself in 1866?
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account