The Rise and Fall of Prohibition: The Human Side of What the Eighteenth Amendment and the Volstead Act Have Done to the United StatesTowne, Charles Hanson
History
The Rise and Fall of Prohibition: The Human Side of What the Eighteenth Amendment and the Volstead Act Have Done to the United States
Towne, Charles Hanson
Prohibition -- United States; United States. Constitution. 18th Amendment
In the State of Nebraska recently an attempt was made to put through
the legislation many autocratic laws. People were not to be allowed to
speak a foreign language, and certain restrictions were to be placed
on the wearing of religious garb, etc. A visitor to that State, George
A. Schreiner, of South Africa, deprecated such legislation, and stated
that “laws of intolerance defeat their own ends.” It is interesting to
see the reactions on those who come to our country for the first time.
Mr. Schreiner expressed himself wisely when he said:
“It all reminds me of the attempt recently made in Japan to put a
law on the statutes against bad thoughts. Of course, that was very
absurd and still, in a way, it was a very honestly meant piece of
legislation. The author of the bill wanted to get at the root of
what he considered an evil--a danger to Japan. Elsewhere and in
your own State the same thing has been attempted by being aimed at,
as it were. I feel that a great deal of intolerance has been born
of the War, but we ought to be fair even with Jupiter and Mars.
Much is blamed on the War, when, in reality, the War served simply
as an excuse to waken latent passions in man.”
_The Outlook_, which is certainly a sane periodical, whose editorial
integrity cannot be doubted, sees a menace in too much legislation.
Only confusion and distrust can result when the people are confronted
with a mass of judicial arguments and interpretations of those
arguments. In a sensible editorial recently, entitled “Why Not
‘Limitation of Legislation’?” the editors spoke their minds thus:
“This harassed old world needs ‘limitation of legislation’ as well
as ‘limitation of armaments.’ Statutes, laws, and regulations of
all sorts make each year confusion worse confounded. It has been
asserted that every person in the United States, unwittingly, in
99 cases out of 100, violates every day some Federal State or
local law or regulation; perhaps the honest judge himself in going
from his home to the court room where he hands down every day
his judgments of justice breaks some minor regulation, for which
offense a policeman, if he were nearby and had studied his book of
regulations carefully enough, could place the eminent judge under
arrest.
“A leading authority on American police administration recently
estimated that the average policeman, to enforce the city
ordinances, State laws, and Congressional enactments, committed in
whole or in part to his charge, must have a working knowledge of
at least 16,000 statutes. This fact was pointed out in a recent
speech in Washington by James A. Emery before the American Cotton
Manufacturers’ Association.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account