The Southern Case for School SegregationKilpatrick, James Jackson
History
The Southern Case for School Segregation
Kilpatrick, James Jackson
African Americans -- Segregation; Segregation -- Southern States
Intelligence testing by racial groups was launched on a large scale
with World War I. As an aid to military authorities, three separate
tests were devised. The first, known as Army A, never was very widely
used; it contained some four hundred items and featured two tests, of
immediate memory and cancellation, which proved to be impracticable.
Analyses of findings were made, however, by Ferguson and by Robert
M. Yerkes, of 10,276 Negro soldiers and 38,628 white soldiers tested
on Army A at Camp Lee and Camp Dix. The median score among Negro
recruits ranged from 14.8 at Lee to 53 at Dix, the white recruits
from 116 at Lee to 171 at Dix.
In an effort to devise a more useful test, a committee of five
psychologists, led by Yerkes, was appointed by the American
Psychological Association in April 1917. They put together tests
that came to be known as Army Alpha and Army Beta. The tests, which
brought together the most advanced psychological knowledge of
their day, still are widely respected by psychologists forty-five
years later. Henry E. Garrett, professor emeritus of psychology at
Columbia University, has said of them that “owing to the size of the
groups and the lack of special selection, the army test data yield
probably the fairest and most unbiased comparison of Negro and white
intelligence which we possess.”
The Alpha test was divided into eight sections, testing the
examinee’s ability in following directions, arithmetic problems,
practical judgment, synonyms and antonyms, disarranged sentences,
completion of number series, analogies, and general information. The
psychologists’ committee realized, however, that because of its heavy
reliance upon literacy and cultural factors, the Alpha test would
tell Army examiners little about the intelligence and capacity of
recruits whose schooling was limited and whose cultural background
was poor. Hence the Beta test was devised, as a nonlanguage test on
which all illiterates could compete equally.
The average score of the white soldier on the Alpha test was 59,
that of the Northern Negro 39, and that of the Southern Negro 12.
The better educational equipment of the whites presumably might
account for some of this astonishing difference, without considering
any questions of innate ability at all. But this superior equipment
did not figure on the Beta test. And on Beta, the whites averaged
43, the Northern Negro 33, and the Southern Negro 20. Analyzing
these Beta findings in one study of men tested at Camp Grant, M.
R. Trabue concluded that the average Northern Negro recruit had an
ability to learn new things about equivalent to that of the average
eleven-year-old white boy, and the average Southern Negro recruit a
mental capacity at the nine-year-old level.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account