The Southern Literary Messenger, Vol. II., No. 8, July, 1836Various
General
The Southern Literary Messenger, Vol. II., No. 8, July, 1836
Various
American literature -- 19th century -- Periodicals
exhaustless treasures, as the repetition of the cabalistic word
“sesame,” used to gain into the robber's cave of the Arabian Nights'
Entertainments. These truly marvellous facilities invented by us
moderns, to expedite the manufacture of profound scholars and
immaculate moralists, as far surpass the clumsy contrivances of our
ancestors, to accomplish the same ends, as that most palatable
expedient for teaching the famous Martinus Scriblerus his alphabet,
exceeded in ingenuity and delectable adaptation to the designed end,
every other scheme devised for a similar purpose. It consisted simply,
in coaxing the little genius to eat his letters cut out of
gingerbread. Oh! the profundities and the altitudes of these {482}
wondrous improvements! when shall we all learn to estimate them as
they deserve? Not that I mean to deny the real advances made in the
arts of teaching, as well as in the general system of education. These
certainly have been very great, and are justly entitled to much
praise. But I believe the facts will warrant me in asserting, that
they fall far short of what they are generally represented to be; and
that, if stripped of all exaggeration, of all false pretension, so as
to be estimated exactly for what they are worth and no more, they will
be found to have gained more in show than use: in other words, that
they are, in no small degree, calculated to make vain, superficial
pretenders to true knowledge, rather than profound scholars and real
proficients in any art or science whatever—unless it be in the art of
puffing, which seems now to have reached its acme of perfection. If
the amount of these improvements were nearly equal to what is claimed
for them, we should scarcely be able to walk along the streets of our
towns and cities, without running our heads against such men as
Pythagoras, Socrates, Aristotle, and Plato. But what is the plain,
stubborn matter of fact? Why, that it is very doubtful, whether the
number of such illustrious men (if such can be found at all,) now
bears an equal proportion to the present population of the world, that
the number did to the population of the period in which the
philosophers just mentioned immortalized their names. There must be
some reason for this, if true, as I confidently believe it to be; and
it must lie much deeper, and have much more force, than the zealous
advocates for the vast superiority of modern over by-gone times in the
arts of teaching, will be willing to allow. May it not be found in the
remarkable fact, that in ancient times, no men occupied a more
elevated rank than _teachers_, while the all important business of
teaching youth was confined to men of the highest order of talent—the
most profound knowledge, and the greatest respectability of character;
whereas, in our days, this indispensable occupation—this profession,
so vitally necessary to human happiness, is permitted to be exercised
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account