Finally the Commission recommended that the Stock Exchange should be incorporated! This was quite revolutionary in its boldness, and it was a distinct recommendation, not a mere suggestion. The Stock Exchange, the Commission thought, should be incorporated by Royal Charter, in order to give permanence to the admittedly excellent rules by which the body was governed. At any election, the Commissioners held, the Committee might be reorganised by the whim of a majority of members, and its existing rules, as well as any further reforms that might be wrought, might be repealed. The Incorporated Stock Exchange, it proposed, should remain governed as it then was, but subject to the provision that no alteration in the rules and regulations should become operative until approved by the President of the Board of Trade or some other competent public authority. At the same time, this outside interference, it was recommended, should be exercised with a sparing hand. Any attempt to reduce the rules to the limits of the ordinary law of the land would, in the opinion of the Commission, be detrimental. The Commission seemed of opinion that the Stock Exchange would welcome incorporation, but it proposed, apparently as a kind of sop, that if it accepted the recommendation it might well be granted a monopoly of stockbroking--in other words, it proposed that if the Stock Exchange were incorporated it should have the exclusive right of licensing people to act as stockbrokers, which, of course, would do away with the outside broker altogether. In any case the Commission seemed to deem it very important that all stockbrokers should be licensed. They used to be so licensed in the City of London by the Corporation, but by degrees the control of the Corporation was broken down. In the event of the Stock Exchange refusing incorporation, the Commission recommended that some public functionary--it seemed fond of public functionaries--should be appointed to exercise authority and discretion in granting and withdrawing stockbrokers' licences, both to members of the Stock Exchange and to others.