The Truth About Jesus : Is He a Myth?: Illustrated — John Shaqi
The Truth About Jesus : Is He a Myth?: IllustratedMangasarian, M. M. (Mangasar Mugurditch)
Religion
The Truth About Jesus : Is He a Myth?: Illustrated
Mangasarian, M. M. (Mangasar Mugurditch)
Jesus Christ -- Historicity; Rationalism
That the authorities of the church realize how damaging to the reality
of the gospel Jesus is the inexplicable silence of Paul concerning
him, may be seen in their vain effort to find in a passage put in
Paul's mouth by the unknown author of the book of _Acts_, evidence
that Paul does quote the sayings of Jesus. The passage referred to is
the following: "It is more blessed to give than to receive." Paul is
made to state that this was a saying of Jesus. In the first place,
this quotation is not in the epistles of Paul, but in the _Acts_, of
which Paul was not the author; in the second place, there is no such
quotation in the gospels. The position, then, that there is not a
single saying of Jesus in the gospels which is quoted by Paul in his
many epistles is unassailable, and certainly fatal to the historicity
of the gospel Jesus.
Again, from Paul himself we learn that he was a zealous Hebrew, a
Pharisee of Pharisees, studying with Gamaliel in Jerusalem, presumably
to become a rabbi. Is it possible that such a man could remain totally
ignorant of a miracle worker and teacher like Jesus, living in the
same city with him? If Jesus really raised Lazarus from the grave,
and entered Jerusalem at the head of a procession, waving branches
and shouting, "hosanna"--if he was really crucified in Jerusalem, and
ascended from one of its environs--is it possible that Paul neither
saw Jesus nor heard anything about these miracles? But if he knew all
these things about Jesus, is it possible that he could go through the
world preaching Christ without ever once referring to them? It is
more likely that when Paul was studying in Jerusalem there was no
miraculous Jesus living or teaching in any part of Judea.
If men make their gods they also make their Christs. * It is
frequently urged that it was impossible for a band of illiterate
fishermen to have created out of their own fancy so glorious a
character as that of Jesus, and that it would be more miraculous to
suppose that the unique sayings of Jesus and his incomparably perfect
life were invented by a few plain people than to believe in his actual
existence. But it is not honest to throw the question into that
form. We do not know who were the authors of the gospels. It is pure
assumption that they were written by plain fishermen. The authors of
the gospels do not disclose their identity. The words, _according_
to Matthew, Mark, etc., represent only the guesses or opinions of
translators and copyists.
* Christianity and Mythology. J. M. Robertson, to whom the
author acknowledges his indebtedness, for the difference
between Paul's Jesus and that of the Gospels.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account