Treatise on Poisons: In relation to medical jurisprudence, physiology, and the practice of physicChristison, Robert, Sir
Science
Treatise on Poisons: In relation to medical jurisprudence, physiology, and the practice of physic
Christison, Robert, Sir
Medical jurisprudence; Toxicology
On the art of secret poisoning, however, as having been once an
important object of medical jurisprudence, it might be expected that
some comments should here be offered. But really I do not see any good
reason for wading through the mass of credulous conjectures and
questionable facts, which have been collected on the subject, and which
have been copied into one modern work after another, for no other cause
than that they are of classic origin, or feed our appetite for the
mysterious. No one now seriously believes that Henry the Sixth was
killed by a pair of poisoned gloves, or Pope Clement the Seventh by a
poisoned torch carried before him in a procession, or Hercules by a
poisoned robe, or that the operation of poisons can be so predetermined
as to commence or prove fatal on a fixed day, and after the lapse of a
definite and remote interval. With regard to the noted instances of
secret poisoning, which occurred towards the close of the seventeenth
century in Italy and France, it is plain to every modern toxicologist,
from the only certain knowledge handed down to us of these events, that
the actors in them owed their success rather to the ignorance of the
age, than to their own dexterity. And as to the refined secrets believed
to have been possessed by them, it is sufficient here to say, that
although we are now acquainted with ten times as many and ten times as
subtle poisons as were known in those days, yet none exist which are
endowed with the hidden qualities once so universally dreaded.
The crime of poisoning, from its nature, must always be a secret one.
But little apprehension need be entertained of the art of secret
poisoning as understood by Toffana or Brinvilliers,[63] or as it might
be improved by a modern imitator. It seems to have escaped the attention
of those who have written on the subject, that the practice of such an
art requires the knowledge not only of a dexterous toxicologist, but
also of a skilful physician; for success must depend on the exact
imitation of some natural disease. It is only among medical men,
therefore, and among the higher orders of them, that a Saint-Croix can
arise now-a days. How little is to be dreaded on that head is apparent
from the domestic history of the European kingdoms for the last half
century, compared with their history some centuries ago. Few medical men
have even been suspected, and those few only upon visionary grounds, and
under the impulse of violent political feeling.[64] In one late instance
only, so far as I am aware, has it been proved that the physician’s art
was actually prostituted to so fearful a purpose; and the detection of
the crime in that case shows how difficult concealment will always be
wherever justice is administered rigorously, and medico-legal
investigations skilfully conducted.[65]
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account