American essays -- 20th century; State, The; World War, 1914-1918
But the emotions that play around the defense of the State do not
take into consideration the pragmatic results. A nation at war, led
by its significant classes, is engaged in liberating certain of its
impulses which have had all too little exercise in the past. It is
getting certain satisfactions and the actual conduct of the war or the
condition of the country are really incidental to the enjoyment of new
forms of virtue and power and aggressiveness. If it could be shown
conclusively that the persecution of slightly disaffected elements
actually increased enormously the difficulties of production and the
organization of the war-technique, it would be found that public policy
would scarcely change. The significant classes must have their pleasure
in hunting down and chastizing everything that they feel instinctively
to be not imbued with the current State-enthusiasm, though the State
itself be actually impeded in its efforts to carry out those objects
for which they are passionately contending. The best proof of this is
that with a pursuit of plotters that has continued with ceaseless
vigilance ever since the beginning of the war in Europe, the concrete
crimes unearthed and punished have been fewer than those prosecutions
for the mere crime of opinion or the expression of sentiments critical
of the State or the national policy. The punishment for opinion has
been far more ferocious and unintermittent than the punishment of
pragmatic crime. Unimpeachable Anglo-Saxon Americans who were freer of
pacifist or socialist utterance than the State-obsessed ruling public
opinion, received heavier penalties and even greater opprobrium, in
many instances, than the definitely hostile German plotter. A public
opinion which, almost without protest, accepts as just, adequate,
beautiful, deserved and in fitting harmony with ideals of liberty
and freedom of speech, a sentence of twenty years in prison for mere
utterances, no matter what they may be, shows itself to be suffering
from a kind of social derangement of values, a sort of social neurosis,
that deserves analysis and comprehension.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account