William Shakespeare: A Critical StudyBrandes, Georg
General
William Shakespeare: A Critical Study
Brandes, Georg
Shakespeare, William, 1564-1616 -- Criticism and interpretation
Juliet has grown up in an unquiet and not too agreeable home. Her
testy, unreasonable father, though not devoid of kindliness, is yet
so brutal that he threatens to beat her and turn her out of doors if
she does not comply with his wishes; and her mother is a cold-hearted
woman, whose first thought, in her rage against Romeo, is to have him
put out of the way by means of poison. She has thus been left for the
most part to the care of the humorous and plain-spoken Nurse, one of
Shakespeare's most masterly figures (foretelling the Falstaff of a few
years later), whose babble has tended to prepare her mind for love in
its frankest manifestations.
Although a child in years, Juliet has the young Italian's mastery in
dissimulation. When her mother proposes to have Romeo poisoned, she
agrees without moving a muscle, and thus secures the promise that no
one but she shall be allowed to mix the potion. Her beauty must be
conceived as dazzling. I saw her one day in the streets of Rome, in all
the freshness of her fourteen years. My companion and I looked at each
other, and exclaimed with one consent, "Juliet!" Romeo's exclamation on
first beholding her--
"Beauty too rich for use, for earth too dear,"
conveys an instant impression of nobility, high mental gifts, and
unsullied purity, combined with the utmost ardour of temperament. In a
few days the child ripens into a heroine.
We make acquaintance with her at the ball in the palace of the
Capulets, and in the moonlit garden where the nightingale sings in
the pomegranate-tree--surroundings which harmonise as completely with
the whole spirit and tone of the play as the biting wintry air on
the terrace at Kronborg, filled with echoes of the King's carouse,
harmonises with the spirit and tone of _Hamlet._ But Juliet is no
mere creature of moonshine. She is practical. While Romeo wanders off
into high-strung raptures of vague enthusiasm, she, on the contrary,
promptly suggests a secret marriage, and promises on the instant to
send the Nurse to him to make a more definite arrangement. After the
killing of her kinsman, it is Romeo who despairs and she who takes up
the battle, daring all to escape the marriage with Paris. With a firm
hand and a steadfast heart she drains the sleeping-potion, and arms
herself with her dagger, so that, if all else fails, she may still be
mistress of her own person.
How shall we describe the love that indues her with all this strength?
Modern critics in Germany and Sweden are agreed in regarding it as
a purely sensual passion, by no means admirable--nay, essentially
reprehensible. They insist that there is a total absence of maidenly
modesty in Juliet's manner of feeling, thinking, speaking, and acting.
She does not really know Romeo, they say; is there anything more, then,
in this unbashful love than the attraction of mere bodily beauty?[4]
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account