Philosophumena; or, The refutation of all heresies, Volume II — David Hume — John Shaqi
Philosophumena; or, The refutation of all heresies, Volume II
David Hume · en
[Footnote 151: διώρθωτο. So that Valentinus was the first to advance
the theory which we find later among the Manichæans that this earth
of ours, instead of being the centre of the universe, was in fact the
lowest and most insignificant of all the worlds, and that salvation
only came to it after the greater universe had been reformed--an
extraordinary conception on the part of one who must have held, like
his contemporaries, geocentric views in astronomy.]
[Footnote 152: Ex. vi. 2, 3.]
[Footnote 153: κατὰ τὴν αὐτὴν ἀκολουθίαν. Here as elsewhere in the
text, ἀκολουθία has the meaning of imitation.]
[Footnote 154: ἰσόζυγος.]
[Footnote 155: ἐπανόρθωσιν, “re-rectification”!]
[Footnote 156: What follows is from Plato’s Second Epistle, which is
thought to have been written after Plato’s return from his third voyage
to Syracuse, and is perhaps rather less suspect than the other Platonic
epistles. Yet the chances of interpolation are so great that no stress
can be laid on the genuineness of any particular passage.]
[Footnote 157: This passage alone is sufficient to make one doubtful
as to the Platonic authorship. If Plato really wanted to keep his
doctrine secret, the last thing he would have done would be to call the
attention of the chance reader to the fact.]
[Footnote 158: Burges translates: “But about a second are the secondary
things and about a third the third.”]
[Footnote 159: Nearly two pages are here omitted from the Epistle.]
[Footnote 160: Possibly an allusion to the Platonic theory that all
learning is remembrance.]
[Footnote 161: Τὰ δὲ νῦν λεγόμενα Σωκράτους. “Said of him” or “said by
him”? The passage is quoted by the Emperor Julian and by Aristides.]
[Footnote 162: So that Hippolytus’ attempt to show that Valentinus
plagiarized from Plato resolves itself into an imaginative
interpretation of a purposely obscure passage in an epistle which is
only doubtfully assigned to Plato. That Valentinus like every one
educated in the Greek learning was influenced by Plato is likely
enough, but that there was any conscious borrowing of tenets is against
probability.]
[Footnote 163: προαρχή τῶν ὅλων Αἰώνων.]
[Footnote 164: That Valentinus is said to have written psalms, see
Tertullian, _de Carne Christi_, I, c. xvii, xx, t. ii, pp. 453, 457
(Oehl.).]