The mill house mystery — John Stuart Mill — John Shaqi
The mill house mystery
John Stuart Mill · en
“I’m going to tell the truth,” cut in Rhoda brusquely. “I’m going to
say that I watched the packing of Mr. Rotherfield’s luggage inside his
car, that I saw the gun-case put in, that I took it out with my own
hands, and that Mr. Rotherfield followed me back into the house,
stopped me, and let me take the picture out.”
“How did you know--supposing this strange story is true--that the
picture was in the gun-case?”
“I guessed it.”
Lady Sarah looked alarmed.
“You are very inquisitive,” she said sharply.
“Oh, Lady Sarah, how can I help it, when such things happen as have
happened here?”
Lady Sarah drew a deep breath.
“Things! What things?” escaped her lips in spite of herself.
“Well, I know more than I have told you. Not through any curiosity on
my part, but because I couldn’t help it.”
Lady Sarah looked askance at her, but did not venture to ask any more
questions.
“Go on,” she said petulantly. “Go on with this fairy tale that you
intend to tell Sir Robert.”
“That’s all. It will be for Sir Robert himself to make inquiries. All
I have to tell him is how I became possessed of the picture.”
“Very well,” said Lady Sarah, in an attitude and with an expression of
calm despair. “And do you know what will happen when you’ve told him?”
“It will not concern me. I shall have done what I had to do, and I
shall go away.”
“After having succeeded in wrecking Sir Robert’s happiness and mine.
Oh, yes, it is of no use to shake your head, that is what you will
have done. Do you think he will be content to receive back the
picture, and to accept your story, without making any inquiries? It is
absurd to think such a thing. He will certainly find out that you have
not told him the truth, because he knows Jack, and can trust him, and
Jack will assure him that there is no truth in your preposterous
story. But you will have sown the seed of mistrust in my husband, and
you will have spoilt every chance there was of our continuing to live
happily together. And that after your lectures to me, after your
assurance that you were so grateful to him that all you wished for was
his happiness!”
Rhoda was crying quietly, with her face hidden. She knew that the
picture drawn by Lady Sarah would probably prove to be, in its main
outlines, correct. Jack and Lady Sarah would certainly deny all that
Rhoda said, and it was scarcely likely that, in the long run, with his
admiration for his wife and his fondness for Jack at war with his
confidence in Rhoda, he would end by taking her part against the other
two.
Nevertheless, even if he allowed Rhoda to go away in disgrace, perhaps
herself under suspicion of having committed the theft, it was probable
that, as Lady Sarah suggested, the seeds of mistrust would have been
sown within him, and there would be a change for the worse in the
domestic life of the household.
Suddenly Rhoda looked up, in desperation.