This is not to say that all the really good fighters were of prehistoric
vintage, for there have been some notable examples of distinction
in recent times. There is no doubt that Joe Louis and Ray Robinson
would have stood out in any era, and Rocky Marciano was as strong and
courageous as any man who ever stepped into the roped square. But the
deterioration of fighters in general is strikingly obvious when I
consider the overwhelming preponderance of old-timers in my ranking
of top ringmen from the first Marquis of Queensberry heavyweight
championship bout between Sullivan and Corbett in 1892 to the present.
Leading my list of fighters whose best performances were given in the
last sixty-six years is my favorite heavyweight, Jack Johnson. I rate
James J. Jeffries second, and close on his heels are Bob Fitzsimmons,
Jack Dempsey, James J. Corbett, Joe Louis, Sam Langford and Gene Tunney,
in that order.
Tunney was not a colorful battler, but he was a cool, mechanical operator
who mastered the technical ends of the game and definitely has been a
much underrated fighter. He proved in his two bouts with Dempsey that he
was far superior to the rest of the heavyweight fighters during the years
that Jack held sway.
Dempsey came at a time when boxing was badly in need of a man of his
stamp. Jess Willard had lifted the crown from Johnson, thus ending the
era of the “white hopes,” but somehow boxing fans could not get it into
their heads that Willard had won the world’s title squarely. His was an
empty triumph that thrilled nobody.
Along came the Mauler from Manassa. Along came Tex Rickard. This
wonderful combination of fighter and promoter revived the sport and
resuscitated its finances, and the old guard suddenly discovered that the
“good old days” had come again. Boxing was lifted into the million-dollar
class. And Dempsey did it. He did it with his dynamic right, his bobbing
and weaving style, his popularity with the public, and his ability to
produce electric shocks. Those qualities make him the fourth greatest
fighter of the modern era in my book.
As for the recently retired, undefeated heavyweight champion, Rocky
Marciano, he was a great hitter, but I’d rate Max Schmeling, of Germany,
above him in the number nine spot.
In the light-heavyweight class, I give the wily Kid McCoy, the corkscrew
artist, top rating, with clever Philadelphia Jack O’Brien next in line,
and Jack Dillon, the “Hoosier Bearcat,” in third place.
Stanley Ketchel, the “Michigan Assassin,” Tommy Ryan, and Harry Greb,
“The Pittsburgh Whirlwind,” occupy the top positions, respectively, among
the middleweights, with Mickey Walker, the “Toy Bulldog,” and “Sugar” Ray
Robinson following in that order.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account