A Beginner's History of Philosophy, Vol. 2: Modern PhilosophyCushman, Herbert Ernest
Philosophy
A Beginner's History of Philosophy, Vol. 2: Modern Philosophy
Cushman, Herbert Ernest
Philosophy -- History
In such an inductive sifting of traditional beliefs, are there any
that can be called knowledge? Is there one whose reliability cannot
be successfully doubted? Not a single one, except the thinking process
itself. I am certain that I am conscious. Even when in my universal
doubt I say that nothing is certain, I am at least certain that I
doubt. I am, therefore, contradicting my universal skepticism. To doubt
is to think; in doubting, consciousness is asserting its existence.
Skepticism is self-contradictory. An induction of our ideas reveals
at least this one absolutely certain principle: I, as thinking,
am. _Cogito ergo sum._ My own existence is an intuitive truth that
accompanies every state of mind. This is the best known portion of
Descartes’s philosophy, and perhaps it is in part to the Latin formula
of it that it owes its widespread acceptance. It is criticised as
trifling, even if it be true; and as reasoning in a circle. Yet
it must be remembered that Descartes does not intend the _ergo sum_
(“therefore I am”) to be a conclusion of a syllogism of which _Cogito_
(“I think”) is the minor premise. This formula is not an inference, but
an intuition, which is revealed by induction as the certain background
of all knowledge.
Three things are to be learned from this fundamental principle, said
Descartes: (1) The first is that man has gained a criterion of truth.
The characteristic of this principle that makes it reliable and certain
is its clearness and distinctness. _Clearness and distinctness of ideas
is the proof of their truth._ All true ideas will therefore have the
mathematical and intuitive certainty that the idea of the existence
of the self has. (2) The second lesson from this fundamental principle
is that the existence of the soul is more certain than that of the
body. The soul is more important and independent than the body. This
is the subjective point of view of modern times. The modern man views
the world as the representation or the creation of his thinking soul.
(3) The third lesson from this principle concerns the nature of the
soul. How long do you exist? As long as you think. (_Sum cogitans._)
True existence is rational thinking, and God alone has it. Feelings and
passions are obscure ideas.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account