A century of science in America : $b with special reference to the American Journal of Science, 1818-1918
History
A century of science in America : $b with special reference to the American Journal of Science, 1818-1918
American journal of science; Science -- United States -- History
_Orogenic Structures._
_Views of Plutonists and Neptunists._
Orogenic structures are, as the name implies, those connected with the
birth of mountains. Nearly synonymous terms are deformative or secondary
structures. On a small scale this division embraces the phenomena
exposed in the rock ledge or quarry face, or in the dips and
dislocations varying from one exposure to another. These structures
include faults, folds, and foliation. On a larger scale are included the
relations of the different ranges of a mountain system to each other,
relations to previous geologic history, relations to the earth as a
whole, and to the forces which have generated the structures.
In order to see the stage of development of this subject in 1818 and its
progress as reflected through the publications of a century, more
particularly in the Journal, it is desirable to turn again to those two
treatises emanating from Edinburgh at the beginning of the nineteenth
century and representing two opposite schools of thought, the Plutonists
and Neptunists.
Playfair, in 1802, devotes nineteen pages to the subject of the
inflection and elevation of strata.[83] He places emphasis on the
characteristic parallelism of the strike of the folds throughout a
region, as shown through the intersection of the folds by a horizontal
plane of erosion. He contrasts this with the arches shown in a
transverse section and enlarges on our ability to study the deeply
buried strata through the denudation of the folded structure. He argues
from these relations that the structures can not be explained by the
vague appeal of the Neptunists to forces of crystallization, to slopes
of original deposition, or to sinking in of the roofs of caverns. The
causes he argues were heat combined with pressure. As to the directions
in which the pressure acted he is not altogether clear, but apparently
regards the pressure as acting in upward thrusts against the sedimentary
planes, the latter yielding as warped surfaces. His method of
presentation is that of inductive reasoning from facts, but he stopped
short of the conception of horizontal compression through terrestrial
contraction.
Jameson, professor of natural history in the same university, in 1808
contemptuously ignores the work of Hutton and Playfair in what he calls
the “_monstrosities_ known under the name of Theories of the Earth.” In
a couple of pages he confuses and dismisses the whole subject of
deformation. He states:[84]
“It is therefore a fact, that all inclined strata, with a very few
exceptions, have been formed so originally, and do not owe their
inclination to a subsequent change.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account