A Class Room Logic: Deductive and Inductive, with Special Application to the Science and Art of TeachingMcNair, George Hastings
Philosophy
A Class Room Logic: Deductive and Inductive, with Special Application to the Science and Art of Teaching
McNair, George Hastings
Logic
With an O proposition the subject is _undistributed_ while the
predicate is distributed. This condition presents a peculiar
difficulty. Consider, for example, the O proposition, “Some men are
not wise.” Convert this into, “Some wise beings are not men,” and the
_undistributed_ subject of the convertend, which is “men,” becomes the
_distributed_ predicate of the converse. _Thus the O proposition cannot
be converted without violating the rule for distribution._
_A Summary of How the Four Logical Propositions May be Converted._
1. _A._ The ordinary A proposition may be converted by _limitation_
only. The co-extensive A may be converted _simply_.
2. _E._ The E proposition is converted _simply_. The E may also be
converted by _limitation_, but the inference thus obtained is
_weakened_.
3. _I._ The I proposition may be converted _simply_ only.
4. _O._ The O proposition _cannot be converted_.
(4) _INFERENCE BY CONTRAVERSION._ (Contraposition).
This mode of inference is usually referred to as inference by
_contraposition_, but contraversion, indicating more definitely the
nature of the process, is a better term. Contraversion involves _two_
steps: First, _obversion_; second, _conversion_. The same principles
and rules evident in these _two_ processes obtain in inference by
contraversion. The following scheme, therefore, ought to be sufficient
to make the matter clear:
_Inference by Contraversion._
1. _The Given Proposition._ 2. _Obverted._
A. All men are mortal. No men are immortal.
All trees are plants. No trees are not-plants.
E. No men are infallible. All men are fallible.
No men are trees. All men are not-trees.
I. Some men are wise. Some men are not not-wise.
O. Some water is not pure. Some water is impure.
Some houses are not white. Some houses are not-white.
3. _Converted; giving the contraverse of the original proposition._
No immortals are men.
No not-plants are trees.
Some fallible beings are men.
Some not-trees are men.
An O cannot be converted, consequently the contraversion of an
I is impossible.
Some impure liquids are water.
Some not-white buildings are houses.
It is indicated in the foregoing scheme that “I” cannot be contraverted.
This is due to the fact that the obverse of an I is an O, and it will
be remembered that “O” cannot be converted. All the other propositions
admit of contraversion.
=4. EPITOME OF THE FOUR PROCESSES OF IMMEDIATE INFERENCE IN CONNECTION
WITH THE FOUR LOGICAL PROPOSITIONS.=
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account