A Class Room Logic: Deductive and Inductive, with Special Application to the Science and Art of TeachingMcNair, George Hastings
Philosophy
A Class Room Logic: Deductive and Inductive, with Special Application to the Science and Art of Teaching
McNair, George Hastings
Logic
_Consequent._ _Antecedent._
5. I will go, unless you wire me to the
contrary.
6. I will pay you, when you present your bill.
7. I shall make the trip in granted that I have no accidents.
ten hours,
8. My overcoat would not have if the door had been locked.
been stolen,
=4. TWO KINDS OF HYPOTHETICAL ARGUMENTS.=
The two kinds of hypothetical syllogisms are the _constructive_ and
_destructive_.
_A constructive hypothetical syllogism is one in which the minor
premise affirms the antecedent._
_A destructive hypothetical syllogism is one in which the minor premise
denies the consequent._
The constructive hypothetical is sometimes referred to as the “_modus
ponens_”; whereas the destructive hypothetical is called the “_modus
tollens_.”
ILLUSTRATIONS:
_Constructive_ Hypothetical Syllogisms.
_Symbols._ _Words._
If A is B, C is D If you are diligent, you will succeed;
A is B And you _are_ diligent,
∴ C is D Therefore you will succeed.
_Destructive_ Hypothetical Syllogisms.
If A is B, C is D If you had been diligent, you would have
succeeded;
C is not D But you did not succeed,
∴ A is not B Therefore you were not diligent.
=5. THE RULE AND TWO FALLACIES OF THE HYPOTHETICAL ARGUMENT.=
From a given hypothetical proposition it is possible to construct
_four_ different hypothetical syllogisms, as the attending
illustrations make evident:
Consider the hypothetical proposition “If it has rained, the ground is
damp.”
(1) Minor premise affirms antecedent.
If it has rained, the ground is damp;
It has rained,
Therefore the ground is damp.
(2) Minor premise denies antecedent.
If it has rained, the ground is damp;
It has not rained,
Therefore the ground is not damp.
(3) Minor premise affirms consequent.
If it has rained, the ground is damp;
The ground is damp,
Therefore it has rained.
(4) Minor premise denies the consequent.
If it has rained, the ground is damp;
The ground is not damp,
Therefore it has not rained.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account