A Class Room Logic: Deductive and Inductive, with Special Application to the Science and Art of TeachingMcNair, George Hastings
Philosophy
A Class Room Logic: Deductive and Inductive, with Special Application to the Science and Art of Teaching
McNair, George Hastings
Logic
This fallacy comes from supposing that the whole thing may be settled
by citing some noted authority who apparently substantiates the
argument advanced.
_Epitome of five forms of Irrelevant Conclusion_:
(1) Appealing to the audience.
(2) Defaming the character of the opponent.
(3) Inability to prove the contradictory.
(4) Gaining the point by force.
(5) Citing authority.
_Non Sequitur (False Consequent)._
_This is the fallacy of deriving a conclusion which does not follow
from the premises._ The fallacy obtains whenever material appears in
the conclusion, which has no bearing on the case under discussion.
“_Irrelevant conclusion_” pertains to the establishment of the premises
while “_non sequitur_” is concerned with the conclusion only. We know
that a logical thinker constructs the conclusion from material already
presented by the premises; “_Non sequitur_” uses material in the
conclusion which is found in neither premise.
“_Non sequitur_” differs from the fallacy of four terms in that the
latter uses the fourth term in the premises while the former introduces
the fourth term in the conclusion, and in a form so well obscured that
it sometimes escapes notice. Illustration:
All men are thinking animals,
Socrates was a man,
∴ Socrates was a scholar.
It does not follow that because a man is a thinking animal that he will
become scholarly.
_False Cause._
_This is the fallacy of assuming that because two happenings have
occurred together several times, the one is the cause of the other._
This very common fallacy is due to lack of discrimination, and to the
exaggerations incident to fear and superstition. Illustrations:
(a) Planting vegetables which grow down, such as the beet, during
the last two days of the waxing moon in order to have a larger
yield. So far as we know the moon has no influence over growing
vegetables.
(b) Thirteen seated at a table is an indication that one of the
number will die during the year. This is one of the most absurd
fallacies that has ever been visited upon an intelligent people.
It is seen that “False Cause” is closely related to “_Non Sequitur_.”
_Complex Question_ (_Double Question_).
_This fallacy obtains when an assumption is put in the form of a
question._
ILLUSTRATIONS:
(a) A wise father who did not want to tempt beyond the yielding
point his three-year-old son, asked, pointing to the scratches on
the new mahogany piano, “Freddie, did you do that last night or
this morning?”
(b) What caused you to desist from slandering your neighbors; New
Year’s resolutions or the preaching of Dominie X?
(c) A daily paper anecdote:
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account