A Class Room Logic: Deductive and Inductive, with Special Application to the Science and Art of TeachingMcNair, George Hastings
Philosophy
A Class Room Logic: Deductive and Inductive, with Special Application to the Science and Art of Teaching
McNair, George Hastings
Logic
As the definition implies, analogy involves an extensive use of types;
let us, therefore, become better acquainted with them as instruments
in analogical inductions. A type is _one_ of a group which embodies the
_essential characteristics_ of that group. How easy and natural it is
to dismiss a complex topic with the citing of an example which may be
regarded as a type; how common is the use of examples in the school
room! On second thought it becomes apparent that analogical induction
by example or type is the most common of all forms of induction either
as a method or a mode of inference. _Analogy by example (or type)
assumes that if two or more things are of the same type, they resemble
each other in every essential property._
Illustrations of analogical inductions by example or type.
(1) _Mathematics._
Example: a + b
a + b
―――――――――――――
a² + ab
+ ab + b²
―――――――――――――
a² + 2ab + b²
Inductive Inference: The square of the sum of two quantities is equal
to the square of the first, plus twice the first by the second, plus
the square of the second.
(2) _Nature._
This corn sent me as a sample produced heavy, full ears, and many of
them; hence (inductive inference), if I plant corn _like this sample_
under like conditions, I will receive in return heavy, full ears, and
many of them.
(3) _Geography._
Cities like New York, located on the coast, possess a larger foreign
element than the inland cities like Philadelphia.
(4) _Grammar._
A noun is the name of anything, as the examples, “George Washington”
and “house” would indicate.
In deriving a generalization from one or two examples the prime
essential is to select types which are _truly representative_.
Often the example used is a special type and in consequence does not
exemplify all of the essential characteristics of the group. To teach
the nature of a parallelogram by using a rectangle only, is an easy way
to commit this error; or one may affirm that the class can easily cover
the work, when the judgment is based entirely on knowledge concerning
the _brightest_ one of the grade.
Type work when judicially used is a positive time saver and a very
present help in times of perplexity. Let the skillful teacher use types
and examples extensively yet cautiously.
THE MARK OF SIMILARITY.
As opposed to analogy by type there is a second form; namely, _analogy
by one or more similar marks or qualities_. This form is best described
by the definition: _When two things resemble each other in a few marks
or qualities they resemble each other in other marks or qualities._
Illustrations of analogy by marks.
(1) Noting that two students have the same surname, I infer that they
are brothers.
(2) A man with a book under his arm rings the door bell and asks to
see “the lady of the house.” At once the conclusion is drawn that
the caller is a book agent.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account