A Class Room Logic: Deductive and Inductive, with Special Application to the Science and Art of TeachingMcNair, George Hastings
Philosophy
A Class Room Logic: Deductive and Inductive, with Special Application to the Science and Art of Teaching
McNair, George Hastings
Logic
Exceptive propositions are universal when the exceptions are mentioned.
Universal propositions necessitate a subject more or less definite, as
the predicate of such must refer to the whole of a _definite_ subject.
It follows that in exceptive statements definiteness is secured when
the exceptions are mentioned, therefore it becomes clear how all
such propositions must be universal. Of the illustrations, the first
and third propositions are universal. Any exceptive proposition is
particular when the exceptions are referred to in general terms or
when the subject is followed by _et cetera_. The second illustrative
proposition is particular.
(7) Exclusive Propositions.
Of all propositions which vary from the logical form the exclusive
is the most misleading. Exclusives are accompanied by such words as
“only,” “alone,” “none but,” and “except.” Their peculiarity rests
in the fact that reference is made to the _whole_ of the predicate,
but only to a _part_ of the subject. For example, in the exclusive
proposition, “Only elements are metals,” _metals_ is referred to as
a whole while _elements_ is considered only in part. The true meaning
is “Some elements are all metals,” or to put it in logical form, “All
metals are elements.” _The easiest way to deal with an exclusive is
to interchange subject and predicate (convert simply) and call the
proposition an A._
PROCESS ILLUSTRATED:
_Exclusive Proposition_ _Reduced to Logical Form_
1. None but high school All who enter Training School
graduates may enter must be high school graduates.
Training School.
2. Only first-class All parlor cars are for
passengers are allowed in first-class passengers.
parlor cars.
3. Residents alone are All who are licensed to teach are
licensed to teach. residents.
4. No admittance except on All who have business may be
business. admitted.
5. Only bad men are not-wise. All who are not-wise are bad men.
6. Only some men are wise. All who are wise are men.
It is claimed by good authority that the real nature of the exclusive
is best expressed by _negating_ the subject and calling the proposition
an E; e. g., exclusive: “Only elements are metals”; logical form: “No
not-elements are metals” (E). In a succeeding chapter it is explained
how an E admits of first simple conversion and then obversion. The
following illustrate these two processes:
_Original E_: “No not-elements are metals.”
_Simple conversion_: “No metals are not-elements.”
_Obversion_: “All metals are elements.”
From this it may be seen that the statement, “The easiest way to deal
with an exclusive is to interchange subject and predicate and call the
proposition an A,” is substantially correct.
(8) Inverted Propositions.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account