A day in old Rome : $b a picture of Roman lifeDavis, William Stearns
History
A day in old Rome : $b a picture of Roman life
Davis, William Stearns
Rome -- Social life and customs
=302. Character Witnesses; Torture of Slave Witnesses.=--One thing
more concerning these trials must be noted: the testimony of Roman
citizens carries much greater weight than that of aliens, and the
unreliability of Græco-Levantines is notorious. Freeborn men, Roman or
provincial, testify under oath. Only accusers have the right to compel
the attendance of unwilling witnesses, but the defense can bring not
merely voluntary witnesses to the facts, but can present as many as ten
_laudatores_, character witnesses, and if men of high standing are
vigorous in their friends’ praises, their opinions will offset very
many ugly facts in the testimony.
Frequently enough, however, the statements of slaves have to be taken.
These wretches, having little better status before the law than
animals, can only testify under torture. No master, nevertheless,
except in cases of treason, can ordinarily be compelled to let his
slaves testify _against_ him, but it is assumed that torture is
necessary if a master voluntarily offers his slave as witness,--for
what slave would dare uncompelled to say anything unwelcome to his
master in view of the terrific flogging waiting after he gets home?
The situation in short as to slave testimony is substantially as in
Athens.[191] This use of the rack and flogging post is one of the worst
blots upon the highly scientific and usually reasonable and humane
judicial system of Rome.
=303. Written Evidence; High Development of the Advocate’s Art.=--On
the other hand much weight is given to reliable written evidence.
Public documents from the record office, and the careful entries on
bankers’ ledgers are continually being introduced as testimony.
Much of the forensic oratory also is of a high order. The rhetoric
schools have not taught their better pupils in vain; despite much
silly display, “appeals to the emotions,” and artificiality, the art
of advocacy has never completely lost touch with the promotion of
justice; and usually the verdict goes still to him who best meets Cato
the Elder’s pungent definition of the true orator, _vir bonus, dicendi
peritus_ (“the good man versed in the art of speech”), and who recalls
that great republican’s classic injunction for all advocates--_rem
tene, verba sequentur_ (“Grasp the subject and the words will
follow”).[192]
In all matters not touching certain high interests the Roman courts are
perhaps as disinterested and clean as human tribunals can well be, and
the average _judex_ is charged with a passionate desire to do that
which is formally right. In the courts the spirit of Rome is often to
be seen at its best.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account