A history of criticism and literary taste in Europe, from the earliest texts to the present day. Volume 1 (of 3), Classical and mediæval criticismSaintsbury, George
History
A history of criticism and literary taste in Europe, from the earliest texts to the present day. Volume 1 (of 3), Classical and mediæval criticism
Saintsbury, George
Criticism -- History; Literature -- History and criticism; Literature, Medieval
Partly by mere induction from actual Greek practice, and partly no doubt
also as a genuine result of Greek [Sidenote: _Defects and drawbacks in
the_ Poetics.] taste and literary philosophy, we find the importance and
the character of certain kinds of literature treated with some
extravagance. The importance of Tragedy (as we are enabled to see
clearly by the invaluable though rather unfair aid of the historic
estimate) is altogether exaggerated. It never, as a matter of fact, has
held anything like the position here assigned to it, save twice in two
thousand years and more, on each occasion for a generation or two only.
And there is no reason, in the order and logic of thought, why it should
hold such a position. It is again clearly evident (though we owe the
clearness again not to our own wits, but to time and chance) that part
of this importance is attained by an illegitimate sacrifice, or an
accidental ignoring, of the just claims of other branches of
literature—by making lyric a mere playhouse handmaid, by converting the
stage into a pulpit, and by blocking out, not merely the existence, but
the very possibility, of the prose novel. We can see further that the
glorious achievements of the three great tragedians whom we in part
possess, and of others, probably not much inferior, whom we have almost
wholly lost, seduced their critic into taking what he found in them too
hastily for what ought to be found in all—induced him (aided no doubt by
the Greek taste generally) to exalt Plot, to depress Character, to put
quite undue stress on artificial Unity. Lastly (to keep to the
_Poetics_), we perceive a most unfortunate, though by no means
inexplicable, tendency to give insufficient weight to Metre, and a
decided inclination, on the one hand not to give quite enough importance
to Diction, and on the other to lay down arbitrary rules about it.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account