A History of Dentistry from the most Ancient Times until the end of the Eighteenth CenturyGuerini, Vincenzo
History
A History of Dentistry from the most Ancient Times until the end of the Eighteenth Century
Guerini, Vincenzo
Dentistry -- History
URBAIN HÉMARD, a surgeon to the Cardinal d’Armagnac, published in 1582,
at Lyons, a booklet entitled: _Recherche de la vraye anathomie des
dents, nature et proprietez d’icelles, où est amplement discouru de
ce qu’elles ont plus que les autres os; avecque les maladies qui leur
adviennent, et les remedies_. This is the first dental monograph that
appeared in France. The pamphlet is written with much erudition, but
its contents are almost entirely taken from preceding authors. Hémard
indicates by the term _deschapellement_ (decrowning) the removal of the
crown of a tooth for curative purposes. He speaks of this operation as
of a method but recently introduced into therapeutics; but, and very
reasonably, too, he shows himself somewhat hostile to such a method of
cure.
As to what concerns the anatomy of the teeth, Hémard’s book does not
contain anything original. The following passage, transcribed by
Portal,[318] shows luminously that Urbain Hémard, instead of making
researches of his own, has simply copied the Italian Eustachius,
translating the latter almost literally. The beauty of it is that
Portal had not noticed the plagiarism in the least, since he says that
if Urbain Hémard had taken into account the researches of Fallopius and
Eustachius as well, his book would have acquired still greater value.
But, in truth, he has taken into account, and has valued the researches
of Eustachius so much as to palm them off as his own! We here
quote, side by side, with a paragraph taken from Hémard’s book, the
corresponding passage of Eustachius, that our readers may be convinced
of the truth of what we have stated:
EUSTACHIUS.
... aperta utraque maxilla occurrunt incisores, canini,
ac tres molares, nimirum secundus, tertius et quartus;
partim mucosi, partim ossei, non obscuræ magnitudinis,
suisque præsepiolis undique vallati:
* * * * *
incisoribus autem et caninis docta manu detractis,
tenuissimum interstitium vix osseum factum conspicitur;
quo pari diligentia amoto, obviam veniunt totidem
incisores et canini pene mucosi et longe minores, qui
post alios priores in propriis caveis latentes, singuli
singulis e regione oppositi collocati essent, nisi
utriusque maxillæ caninus magna ex parte proximo incisori
incumberet, eumque propterea fere occultaret.[319]
Primorum molarium et genuinorum qui circa septennium ac
longe etiam postea oriuntur, fateor me nullum vestigium
vidisse.
HÉMARD.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account