In South America the history of the tapirs is even shorter and less eventful than that of the horses; the latter, as we have seen, reached the southern continent in the Pliocene and there gave rise to a number of peculiar and characteristic genera, but the tapirs have been found only in the Pleistocene of Argentina and Brazil and only the modern genus is represented. Wofully broken and incomplete as the developmental history of the tapirs still is, the fragments are nevertheless sufficient to show a mode of evolution differing in certain important respects from that followed by the horses or †titanotheres. Certain features are common to all three groups, such as the increase in size and in proportionate stoutness from stage to stage and the gradual enlargement and complication of the premolar teeth. On the other hand, the tapirs have been very conservative, and they underwent far less radical changes than did either of the other families. Aside from the proboscis and the modifications of the skull which the development of that organ necessitated, these animals remain to-day very nearly what they were in Oligocene times. This, then, is an example of development practically restricted to a few organs, while all the other parts of the structure changed but little. [Illustration: FIG. 171.—Upper teeth, left side, of tapirs, showing comparative sizes. _A_, _†Protapirus validus_, White River Oligocene. _B_, _Tapirus terrestris_, modern. _i3_, external incisor. _c_, canine. _m1_, first molar.] The extinct †lophiodonts, like the tapirs, of which they would seem to have been near relatives, are known only from incomplete material, and comparatively little has been learned regarding their history. While they were abundant and varied in Europe, during the Eocene epoch, they never were a striking or prominent element among the mammals of North America, where they persisted one stage later, and they did not reach South America. In North America they are found from the Wasatch to the White River.