A History of Matrimonial Institutions, Vol. 2 of 3Howard, George Elliott
History
A History of Matrimonial Institutions, Vol. 2 of 3
Howard, George Elliott
Families; Marriage -- History
[Footnote 153: So in India: POLLOCK AND MAITLAND, _op. cit._,
II, 391 n. 2: citing Maine's speech on the "Remarriage of Native
Converts," in _Memoir and Speeches and Minutes_ (London, 1892),
130. _Cf._ especially ESMEIN, _op. cit._, II, 268 ff., who
discusses some of the "curious problems" growing out of this
rule.]
By the second exception the church found herself entangled in the
subtle theory accepted after Peter Lombard that a contract _de
praesenti_ constitutes a valid marriage whether followed by actual
wedded life or not.[154] The mature doctrine of the canon law,
which is still obeyed by the Roman church, permits the unconsummate
marriage _de praesenti_ to be dissolved through papal dispensation
or _ipso facto_ by taking holy orders.[155] Here in effect the
older theory of Gratian, that only the consummate marriage is
a real marriage, is adopted for a practical end, although it is
absolutely irreconcilable with the still accepted orthodox theory of
Lombard, whose enforcement in the ecclesiastical courts has been the
cause of so much evil in western Christendom.[156]
[Footnote 154: For the evils arising in clandestine marriage
_de praesenti_, the complexity of the law of forbidden degrees,
and the conflicting jurisdiction of the temporal and spiritual
courts, see chap. viii above.]
[Footnote 155: FREISEN, _op. cit._, 826 ff., 212 ff.,
shows that the _dispensatio summi pontificis a matrimonio
rato nondum consummato_ originated with the reforms of
Alexander III.; and argues rightly that these two kinds of
dissolution--dispensation and orders--are in harmony with the
rule of indissolubility according to the doctrine of Gratian,
but not according to the existing theory. Thus, of the old
eight causes which were sufficient of themselves to dissolve
_matrimonium initiatum_--identical with the later _sponsalia de
praesenti_--holy orders alone remains; the papal dispensation has
taken the place of the other seven: _ibid._, 827, 829; _cf._ on
these exceptions SCHEURL, _Das gem. deut. Eherecht_, 278-86.]
[Footnote 156: See chaps. vii and viii, above.]
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account