A History of Science — Volume 1Williams, Henry Smith
History
A History of Science — Volume 1
Williams, Henry Smith
Science -- History
Numerous other of the studies of Archimedes having reference to conic
sections, properties of curves and spirals, and the like, are too
technical to be detailed here. The extent of his mathematical knowledge,
however, is suggested by the fact that he computed in great detail the
number of grains of sand that would be required to cover the sphere of
the sun's orbit, making certain hypothetical assumptions as to the size
of the earth and the distance of the sun for the purposes of argument.
Mathematicians find his computation peculiarly interesting because it
evidences a crude conception of the idea of logarithms. From our present
stand-point, the paper in which this calculation is contained has
considerable interest because of its assumptions as to celestial
mechanics. Thus Archimedes starts out with the preliminary assumption
that the circumference of the earth is less than three million stadia.
It must be understood that this assumption is purely for the sake of
argument. Archimedes expressly states that he takes this number because
it is "ten times as large as the earth has been supposed to be by
certain investigators." Here, perhaps, the reference is to Eratosthenes,
whose measurement of the earth we shall have occasion to revert to in a
moment. Continuing, Archimedes asserts that the sun is larger than the
earth, and the earth larger than the moon. In this assumption, he says,
he is following the opinion of the majority of astronomers. In the third
place, Archimedes assumes that the diameter of the sun is not more than
thirty times greater than that of the moon. Here he is probably basing
his argument upon another set of measurements of Aristarchus, to
which, also, we shall presently refer more at length. In reality, his
assumption is very far from the truth, since the actual diameter of the
sun, as we now know, is something like four hundred times that of the
moon. Fourth, the circumference of the sun is greater than one side of
the thousand-faced figure inscribed in its orbit. The measurement, it is
expressly stated, is based on the measurements of Aristarchus, who makes
the diameter of the sun 1/170 of its orbit. Archimedes adds, however,
that he himself has measured the angle and that it appears to him to be
less than 1/164, and greater than 1/200 part of the orbit. That is to
say, reduced to modern terminology, he places the limit of the sun's
apparent size between thirty-three minutes and twenty-seven minutes of
arc. As the real diameter is thirty-two minutes, this calculation is
surprisingly exact, considering the implements then at command. But
the honor of first making it must be given to Aristarchus and not to
Archimedes.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account