A History of Science — Volume 4Williams, Henry Smith
History
A History of Science — Volume 4
Williams, Henry Smith
Science -- History
The Animists taught that the soul performed functions of ordinary life
in man, while the life of lower animals was controlled by ordinary
mechanical principles. Stahl supported this theory ardently, sometimes
violently, at times declaring that there were "no longer any doctors,
only mechanics and chemists." He denied that chemistry had anything to
do with medicine, and, in the main, discarded anatomy as useless to the
medical man. The soul, he thought, was the source of all vital movement;
and the immediate cause of death was not disease but the direct action
of the soul. When through some lesion, or because the machinery of the
body has become unworkable, as in old age, the soul leaves the body
and death is produced. The soul ordinarily selects the channels of the
circulation, and the contractile parts, as the route for influencing
the body. Hence in fever the pulse is quickened, due to the increased
activity of the soul, and convulsions and spasmodic movements in disease
are due, to the, same cause. Stagnation of the blood was supposed to
be a fertile cause of diseases, and such diseases were supposed to
arise mostly from "plethora"--an all-important element in Stahl's
therapeutics. By many this theory is regarded as an attempt on the
part of the pious Stahl to reconcile medicine and theology in a
way satisfactory to both physicians and theologians, but, like many
conciliatory attempts, it was violently opposed by both doctors and
ministers.
A belief in such a theory would lead naturally to simplicity in
therapeutics, and in this respect at least Stahl was consistent. Since
the soul knew more about the body than any physician could know, Stahl
conceived that it would be a hinderance rather than a help for the
physician to interfere with complicated doses of medicine. As he
advanced in age this view of the administration of drugs grew upon him,
until after rejecting quinine, and finally opium, he at last used only
salt and water in treating his patients. From this last we may judge
that his "system," if not doing much good, was at least doing little
harm.
The theory of the Vitalists was closely allied to that of the Animists,
and its most important representative, Paul Joseph Barthez, was a
cultured and eager scientist. After an eventful and varied career as
physician, soldier, editor, lawyer, and philosopher in turn, he finally
returned to the field of medicine, was made consulting physician by
Napoleon in 1802, and died in Paris four years later.
The theory that he championed was based on the assumption that there was
a "vital principle," the nature of which was unknown, but which differed
from the thinking mind, and was the cause of the phenomena of life. This
"vital principle" differed from the soul, and was not exhibited in human
beings alone, but even in animals and plants. This force, or whatever it
might be called, was supposed to be present everywhere in the body, and
all diseases were the results of it.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account