A History of Science — Volume 4Williams, Henry Smith
History
A History of Science — Volume 4
Williams, Henry Smith
Science -- History
In America, indeed, there being no Middle Age precedents to crystallize
into established customs, the treatment accorded the insane had seldom
or never sunk to this level. Partly for this reason, perhaps, the work
of Dr. Rush at the Philadelphia Hospital, in 1784, by means of which the
insane came to be humanely treated, even to the extent of banishing the
lash, has been but little noted, while the work of the European leaders,
though belonging to later decades, has been made famous. And perhaps
this is not as unjust as it seems, for the step which Rush took, from
relatively bad to good, was a far easier one to take than the leap from
atrocities to good treatment which the European reformers were obliged
to compass. In Paris, for example, Pinel was obliged to ask permission
of the authorities even to make the attempt at liberating the insane
from their chains, and, notwithstanding his recognized position as a
leader of science, he gained but grudging assent, and was regarded as
being himself little better than a lunatic for making so manifestly
unwise and hopeless an attempt. Once the attempt had been made, however,
and carried to a successful issue, the amelioration wrought in the
condition of the insane was so patent that the fame of Pinel's work at
the Bicetre and the Salpetriere went abroad apace. It required, indeed,
many years to complete it in Paris, and a lifetime of effort on the
part of Pinel's pupil Esquirol and others to extend the reform to the
provinces; but the epochal turning-point had been reached with Pinel's
labors of the closing years of the eighteenth century.
The significance of this wise and humane reform, in the present
connection, is the fact that these studies of the insane gave emphasis
to the novel idea, which by-and-by became accepted as beyond question,
that "demoniacal possession" is in reality no more than the outward
expression of a diseased condition of the brain. This realization made
it clear, as never before, how intimately the mind and the body are
linked one to the other. And so it chanced that, in striking the
shackles from the insane, Pinel and his confreres struck a blow also,
unwittingly, at time-honored philosophical traditions. The liberation
of the insane from their dungeons was an augury of the liberation of
psychology from the musty recesses of metaphysics. Hitherto psychology,
in so far as it existed at all, was but the subjective study of
individual minds; in future it must become objective as well, taking
into account also the relations which the mind bears to the body, and in
particular to the brain and nervous system.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account