Lassalle held that the customary standard of living and the operation of
the law generally were subject to variation. Still it may reasonably be
maintained that he has not sufficiently considered the fact that, like
capital, the Iron Law of Wages is an historical category. He has not
overlooked the fact, and could hardly do so, as the Iron Law is an
implicate and result of the domination of capital. But his method of
exposition is too much the controversial one, of pressing it as an
_argumentum ad hominem_ against his opponents in Germany, and, as usual,
in controversy truth is liable to suffer. It may therefore be argued
that under the competitive system as now existing, changes have occurred
which render Lassalle’s theory of the Iron Law inaccurate and untenable.
Even while the present system continues to prevail, the law may undergo
very extensive modification through the progress of education and
organisation among the workmen, and through the general advance of
society in morality and enlightenment. The question of modification of
the Iron Law is one of degree, and it may fairly be contended by critics
of Lassalle that he has not recognised it to a sufficient degree.
On the other hand, it may also be rationally maintained that in so far
as education and organisation prevail among the workmen, in so far does
capitalism, with all its conditions and implicates, tend to be
superseded. Trade Unions, Co-operative Societies, Factory Legislation,
are all forms of the social control of economic processes, inconsistent
with competitive economics. The more they gain ground, the more does
capitalism tend to break up and disappear. From this higher point of
view, we may fairly contend that considerations which have been urged as
destructive of Lassalle’s argument are really symptoms of the decline of
capitalism. The Iron Law is an inevitable result of the historical
conditions contemplated by Lassalle. These conditions have changed, but
the change means that capitalism is passing away. We are thus thrown
back on the wider question, whether capitalism is disappearing, a
question which it would at present be premature to discuss.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account