In any case the position of Lassalle is perfectly clear. He accepted the
orthodox political economy in order to show that the inevitable
operation of its laws left no hope for the working class; and that no
remedy could be found except by abolishing the conditions in which those
laws have their validity—in other words, by abolishing the present
relations of labour and capital altogether. The great aim of his
agitation was to bring forward a scheme which would strike at the root
of the evil. The remedy for the evil condition of things connected with
the Iron Law of Wages is to secure the workmen the full produce of their
labour, by combining the functions of workmen and capitalists through
the establishment of productive associations. The distinction between
labourer and capitalist is thereby abolished. The workman becomes
producer, and for remuneration receives the entire produce of his
labour.
The associations founded by Schulze-Delitzsch, Lassalle went on to
argue, would effect no substantial improvement in the condition of the
working class. The unions for the supply of credit and raw materials do
not benefit the working class as such, but only the small hand-workers.
But hand-labour is an antiquated form of industry, which is destined to
succumb before the large industry equipped with machinery and an
adequate capital. To provide the hand-workers with the means of
continuing their obsolete trades is only to prolong the agony of an
assured defeat.
The consumers’ unions, or co-operative stores as we call them in
England, also fail, because they do not help the workman at the point
where he needs it most, as producers. Before the seller, as before the
policeman, all men are equal; the only thing the seller cares for is
that his customers are able to pay. In discussing the Iron Law, we saw
that the workman must be helped as producer—that is, in securing a
better share of his product. The consumers’ unions may indeed give a
restricted and temporary relief. So long as the unions include only a
limited number of workmen, they afford relief by cheapening the means of
subsistence, inasmuch as they do not lower the general rate of wages.
But in proportion as the unions embrace the entire working class and
thereby cause a general cheapening of the means of subsistence, the Iron
Law of Wages will take effect. For the average wage is only the
expression in money of the customary means of subsistence. The average
wage will fall in proportion to the general cheapening of the means of
subsistence, and all the pains taken by the workmen in founding and
conducting the consumers’ unions will be labour lost. They will only
enable the workman to subsist on a smaller wage.
The only effectual way to improve the condition of the working class is
through the free individual association of the workers, by its
application and extension to the great industry. The working class must
be its own capitalist.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive