A history of the Irish poor law, in connexion with the condition of the peopleNicholls, George, Sir
History
A history of the Irish poor law, in connexion with the condition of the people
Nicholls, George, Sir
Poor laws -- Ireland -- History
“The objections usually urged against the introduction of Poor Laws into
Ireland, are founded on an anticipated demoralization of the
peasantry—and on the probable amount of the charge. The first
objection derives its force from the example of England under the
old Poor Law; but the weight of this objection is destroyed by the
improved administration under the new law, which is rapidly
eradicating the effects of previous abuse; and will, there is good
reason to believe, effectually prevent their recurrence. This belief
is founded on the experience of the effects of the system in every
instance in which it has been brought into operation, and
particularly in two important parishes in Nottinghamshire, where the
workhouse principle was first established in its simplicity and
efficiency fifteen or sixteen years ago, and where it has continued
to be equally effective up to the present time. Similar results have
invariably attended its application in the unions formed under the
new law, which are conducted essentially upon the same principle,
but with a superior combination of machinery, and administrative
arrangement.
“With respect to the second objection, founded on the probable amount of
expenditure, it may be remarked that the Irish population, like
every other, must be supported in some way out of the resources of
the country; and it does not follow that the establishment of such a
system of relief will greatly increase the charge, if it increase it
at all. During the progress of my inquiries, I was often told that
the recognition of any legal claim for relief would lead to
universal pauperism, and would amount to a total confiscation of
property. Many Irish landowners appeared to participate in this
apprehension—under the influence of which it seems to have been
overlooked, that the only legal claim for relief in England is
founded on the actual destitution of the claimant, and that as the
existence of destitution is the ground of the claim, so is its
removal the measure of relief to be afforded. This, if the
destitution be rightly tested, will be a sufficient protection to
property. At present there is no test of destitution in Ireland. The
mendicant, whether his distress be real or fictitious, claims and
receives his share of the produce of the soil in the shape of
charity, before the landlord can receive his portion in the shape of
rent, and before the tenant has ascertained whether he is a gainer
or a loser by his labours and his risks. The mendicant’s claim has
now precedence over every other. If the whole property of Ireland
was rated to the relief of the poor, it would be no more; but in
such case the charge would be equally borne, whereas at present it
is unequal, and tends to evil in its application.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account