A history of the Irish poor law, in connexion with the condition of the peopleNicholls, George, Sir
History
A history of the Irish poor law, in connexion with the condition of the people
Nicholls, George, Sir
Poor laws -- Ireland -- History
“It is impossible to mix with the Irish people without noticing the
great influence of the clergy, and it seemed important therefore to
ascertain their views in regard to a poor-law. I discussed the
subject with many of them, as well Roman catholic as protestant, in
all parts of the country; and I found them, with few exceptions,
decidedly favourably to such a law. In the cases where they were not
so, it appeared to be owing to an apprehension that their influence
might be lessened, by taking from them the distribution of the alms
which now pass through their hands; but this feeling was of rare
occurrence, and I am warranted in saying, that the clergy of every
denomination are almost unanimously favourable to a system of Poor
Laws for Ireland. This was perhaps to be expected, the duties of the
clergy leading them to mix more with the people, and to see more of
their actual wants, than any other class of persons. The shopkeepers
too, and manufacturers and dealers generally, I found favourable to
a poor-law. They declared that they should be gainers at the end of
the year, whatever might be the amount legally assessed upon them;
for that they could neither close their doors, nor turn their backs
upon the wretched objects who were constantly applying to them;
whilst the gentry, if resident, were in a great measure protected
from such applications, and if non-resident, escaped them
altogether.
“A legal provision for the destitute, is moreover an indispensable
preliminary to the suppression of mendicancy. If the state offers an
alternative, it may prohibit begging—it would be in vain to do so
otherwise, for the law would be opposed to our natural sympathies,
and would remain inoperative. This was the course adopted in
England, where it was long endeavoured to repress vagrancy by severe
enactments, but apparently with little advantage. At last the offer
of relief was coupled with the prohibition of mendicancy, and until
our Poor Law administration became corrupt, with perfect success. To
establish a poor-law, then, is I believe a necessary preliminary to
the suppression of mendicancy. That it will be, on the whole,
economical to do this in Ireland, it is I think scarcely possible to
doubt; but whether it be so or not, the advantage both morally and
socially of removing such an evil, is beyond question important.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account