A history of the Irish poor law, in connexion with the condition of the peopleNicholls, George, Sir
History
A history of the Irish poor law, in connexion with the condition of the people
Nicholls, George, Sir
Poor laws -- Ireland -- History
“In my inquiries with regard to these points, I endeavoured to exercise
a care and vigilance proportioned to their importance. The inquiry
was entered upon under an apprehension that the workhouse would be
less efficient in Ireland, than experience had shown it to be in
England; and that it would probably be applicable to the able-bodied
in a limited degree only, if applicable to them at all. I was
doubtful also, whether it would be practicable to control any
considerable number of the able-bodied in a workhouse—whether the
proneness of the Irish peasantry to outrage and insubordination
would not, as had often been represented, lead them to break through
all restraint, and perhaps demolish the building, and commit other
acts of violence. The probability of such outrage is strongly
insisted upon by the Commissioners of Inquiry, and the same argument
was urged upon me by some persons with whom I communicated in
Dublin. In the progress of my inquiries however, I soon found reason
for concluding that there was no ground for apprehension, either as
to the applicability of the workhouse for the purposes of relief, or
as to any danger of resistance to such a system of classification
and discipline within it, as would make it a test of destitution. In
the several ‘houses of industry’ established in Ireland, a strict
separation of the sexes is enforced, and a discipline more or less
approximating to our workhouse discipline is established. No spirits
are admitted, and on the whole, there is enough in these
institutions to render them distasteful as places of partial
restraint. Yet from no governor of a house of industry could I learn
that resistance had ever been made to their regulations, and
surprise was even expressed at my thinking it necessary to make the
inquiry. I received the same opinion from the governors of gaols. In
short, every man whom I conversed with, who had any experience of
the habits of the people, declared that the peasantry are perfectly
tractable, and never think of opposing authority, unless stimulated
by drink, or urged on by that species of combination for securing
the occupancy of land, which has become so common in certain
districts. Neither of these influences will interfere with the
establishment of a workhouse, or the regulation of its inmates, all
of whom will have sought refuge in it voluntarily, and may quit it
at any moment. As regards the security of the workhouse, therefore,
and the establishment of a system of discipline as strict as that
maintained in the English workhouses, I believe that there will be
neither danger nor difficulty.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account