A history of the Irish poor law, in connexion with the condition of the peopleNicholls, George, Sir
History
A history of the Irish poor law, in connexion with the condition of the people
Nicholls, George, Sir
Poor laws -- Ireland -- History
“The foregoing appear to be the only points requiring especial
attention, in framing a poor-law for Ireland, although there are
several other matters of minor interest not to be overlooked. The
‘Poor Law Amendment Act’ should, I think, be taken as a guide in
framing the measure, and the language, order, and general provisions
of that Act should be adhered to, except where the contrary is
herein indicated, or where a variation is obviously necessary. There
will be much practical convenience in thus assimilating the two
statutes, which provide for poor-law administration in the two
countries. A measure framed on the principles developed in this
Report, is I think necessary for Ireland. Unless the people are
protected from the effects of destitution, no great or lasting
improvement in their social condition can be expected. The
establishment of a poor-law is, I conceive, the first step necessary
to this end; and followed as it will be by other ameliorations, to
the introduction of which it is a necessary preliminary, we may hope
that it will ultimately prove the means of securing for Ireland the
full amount of those benefits which ought to arise from her various
local advantages, and the natural fertility of her soil.
“The proposed measure may, I believe, be carried into effect, either by
means of a separate commission in Ireland, or by the existing
English Poor Law Commission. One of these modes, I presume, must be
adopted; and before deciding which, it will be necessary to consider
the advantages and disadvantages of each. In doing this, it is
important to bear in mind, that it is the English Poor Law system
which is now proposed to be established; and that the knowledge and
experience acquired in working that system, can be best made
available for Ireland, by employing individuals conversant with the
English practice. If there should be a separate commission for
Ireland, it would be necessary that the commissioners should be
acquainted with the English Poor Law, as now administered; and this,
I apprehend, would exclude most of those Irishmen who might
otherwise be deemed qualified for the office. Such exclusion,
however necessary, would have an ungracious appearance, and might
excite angry comment. But independent of this consideration, if
there were a separate commission, the law would be similar in both
countries, but the practice might become widely different, as was
the case in different parts of England under the old Poor Law
administration. With two commissions, there might possibly be no
unity of principle,—there would certainly be no unity of action,—and
probably no identity of result. Unless the existing English Poor Law
Commission should be unequal to the additional duty of introducing
the proposed law into Ireland, or unless it should appear that the
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account