The more one studies the _Praise of Folly_, the more evident it becomes
that Erasmus did not intend to write a satire on human weakness in
general: the book is the most severe attack on the mediæval Church that
had, up to that time, been made; and it was meant to be so. The author
wanders from his main theme occasionally, but always to return to the
insane follies of the religious life sanctioned by the highest authorities
of the mediæval Church. Popes, bishops, theologians, monks, and the
ordinary lay Christians, are all unmitigated fools in their ordinary
religious life. The style is vivid, the author has seen what he describes,
and he makes his readers see it also. He writes with a mixture of light
mockery and bitter earnestness. He exposes the foolish questions of the
theologians; the vices and temporal ambitions of the Popes, bishops, and
monks; the stupid trust in festivals, pilgrimages, indulgences, and
relics. The theologians, the author says, are rather dangerous people to
attack, for they come down on one with their six hundred conclusions and
command him to recant, and if he does not they declare him a heretic
forthwith. The problems which interest them are:
“Whether there was any instant of time in the divine generation?
... Could God have taken the form of a woman, a devil, an ass, a
gourd, or a stone? How the gourd could have preached, wrought
miracles, hung on the cross?”(125)
He jeers at the Popes and higher ecclesiastics:
“Those supreme Pontiffs who stand in the place of Christ, if they
should try to imitate His life, that is, His poverty, His toil,
His teaching, His cross, and His scorn of this world ... what
could be more dreadful!... We ought not to forget that such a mass
of scribes, copyists, notaries, advocates, secretaries,
mule-drivers, grooms, money-changers, procurers, and gayer persons
yet I might mention, did I not respect your ears,—that this whole
swarm which now burdens—I beg your pardon, honours—the Roman See
would be driven to starvation.”(126)
As for the monks:
“The greater part of them have such faith in their ceremonies and
human traditions, that they think one heaven is not reward enough
for such great doings.... One will show his belly stuffed with
every kind of fish; another will pour out a hundred bushels of
psalms; another will count up myriads of fasts, and make up for
them all again by almost bursting himself at a single dinner.
Another will bring forward such a heap of ceremonies that seven
ships would hardly hold them; another boast that for sixty years
he has never touched a penny except with double gloves on his
hands.... But Christ will interrupt their endless bragging, and
will demand—‘Whence this new kind of Judaism?’
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account