Benton seemed embarrassed, but at length said he supposed he had not done so because he did not think of them at the time. Littell waited patiently till the answer was forthcoming, and then continued: "Now tell the jury was not the real reason you did not tell these things at that time because it had not then occurred to you that suspicion would attach to Winters?" "Yes," he admitted, after some hesitation, "I expect that was the reason." "And," continued Littell, "when you found later that suspicion had attached to Winters, and that he was arrested for the murder, did you not then tell these things because you thought they would strengthen the case against him?" "Yes," he replied, "I think they are evidence against him." "And why should you wish to give evidence against him? Do you think him guilty?" was the next question. This was a little further than Benton was willing to go, and he answered that he did not know. "Well," said Littell; "let us see if we cannot find out what you really do know about it; you probably have more knowledge of the conditions surrounding the case than has any one else." And then, by further interrogation, he elicited the fact that the front door of the house was fastened and required a latch-key to open it when Benton arrived the morning of the murder, and also that while he had frequently admitted Winters to the house, he had never known him to possess a key to the premises. "And how, then, do you think he got in on this night?" Littell continued. Benton probably recalled his unsuccessful attempt to explain this problem to me on another occasion, for he made no effort to do so now, merely acknowledging lamely that he did not understand how he had obtained admission. "And yet," continued Littell, "you have said everything you could to the jury to make it appear that Winters was White's murderer." Benton did not attempt to answer this charge and seemed anxious to evade further questions, but Littell showed no disposition to let him off, but leaving his seat took his stand at Benton's elbow and continued his questions at close range, emphasizing each one: "As a matter of fact, don't you know, or at least are you not satisfied, that Winters had no key to White's house?" he asked. Accustomed to render obedience to Littell, and by this time thoroughly cowed, Benton was no longer capable of resistance, and assented obediently to the question. "And do you not know also," Littell continued, "that whoever secured access to White's room that night and killed him, had, in all probability, a key to the house?" and again Benton assented. "Then it hardly seems likely that Winters was that man, does it?" he concluded,--and the witness had nothing to answer. Littell next questioned him about White's habits and his relations with other men, and extracted the admission that for some time before his death White had seemed worried and had talked vaguely about some trouble and some person.