Two views of the nature of these bodies have been given in vol. 1, (see pages 260, and 484, &c.). In the former they are considered as simple metals; in the latter, as compound bodies resulting from the abstraction of oxygen from the hydrates of potash and soda; or as being constituted of 1 atom of hydrogen united to 1 atom of pure potash or soda respectively. Those who have had the most experience on these elements, Sir H. Davy, and M. M. Gay Lussac and Thenard, seem now to concur in the former view, and it has been adopted by most chemists. Part of the objections which we made to this view have been obviated, it should seem, by establishing the fact, that oxymuriatic gas and hydrogen gas united, form muriatic acid gas. There are still, however, difficulties to remove before this view can be considered perfectly satisfactory; but they are not greater perhaps than would attach to any other explanation of the facts connected with the subject. Besides potassium and sodium, experience as well as analogy would seem to render probable, if not to establish, the existence of barium, strontium, and calcium as metals, of which barytes, strontites, and lime are the protoxides, as potash and soda are of the other two metals; (other oxides of potassium and sodium are stated, see page 55-57); barium has a deutoxide, and probably calcium likewise. The rest of the earths, as magnesia, alumine, silex, &c. are by analogy considered by most chemists as oxides of particular metals, but the proportions of their elements have not been determined. ALUM. At page 531, vol. 1, we have given the constitution of this important salt, as under: since that time Mr. R. Phillips has announced another view of it; and Dr. Thomson has published one differing from both of these. They are as follow: _Dalton_-- 1 atom sulphate of potash. 4 atoms sulphate of alumine. 30 atoms water. _Phillips_-- 1 atom bisulphate of potash. 2 atoms sulphate of alumine. 22 atoms water. _Thomson_-- 1 atom sulphate of potash. 3 atoms sulphate of alumine. 25 atoms water. Notwithstanding these differences, there is a near approximation in all three, in regard to the quantities of acid, alumine, potash, and water in the salt. This is accounted for partly in the different relative weights of the atoms, as estimated by the different analysts, but chiefly in that of alumine. Some very curious results occurred to me about 10 years ago in analysing alum; they were new to me, but I have since found they had been previously discovered by Scheele. (See his essay on silex, clay, and alum, 1776.) As his observations are not to be found in any of our elementary books that I have seen, I shall give the particulars of my own experiments here.