It is certain, that if the author had not striven to make Cornelia
witty, he would not have been guilty of the faults which, after being so
long applauded, are now perceived. The actresses can scarcely longer
palliate them, by a studied loftiness of demeanor and an imposing
elevation of voice.
The better to feel how much mere wit is below natural sentiment, let us
compare Cornelia with herself, where, in the same tirade, she says
things quite opposite:
_Je dois toutefois rendre grâce aux dieux_
_De ce qu'en arrivant je trouve en ces lieux,_
_Que César y commande, et non pas Ptolemée._
_Hélas! et sous quel astre, ó ciel, m'as-tu formée,_
_Si je leur dois des vœux, de ce qu'ils ont permis,_
_Que je recontre ici mes plus grands ennemis,_
_Et tombe entre leurs mains, plutôt qu'aux mains d'un prince_
_Qui doit à mon époux son trône et sa province._--ID.
Yet have I cause to thank the gracious gods,
That Cæsar here commands--not Ptolemy.
Alas! beneath what planet was I formed,
If I owe thanks for being thus permitted
Here to encounter my worst enemies
And fall into their hands, rather than those
Of him who to my husband owes his throne?
Let us overlook the slight defects of style, and consider how mournful
and becoming is this speech; it goes to the heart: all the rest dazzles
for a moment, and then disgusts. The following natural lines charm all
readers:
_O vous! à ma douleur objet terrible et tendre,_
_Éternel entretien de haine et de pitié,_
_Restes de grand Pompée, écoutez sa moitié, etc._
O dreadful, tender object of my grief,
Eternal source of pity and of hate,
Ye relics of great Pompey, hear me now--
Hear his yet living half.
It is by such comparisons that our taste is formed, and that we learn to
admire nothing but truth in its proper place. In the same tragedy,
Cleopatra thus expresses herself to her confidante, Charmion:
_Apprends qu'une princesse aimant sa renommée,_
_Quand elle dit qu'elle aime, est sure d'être aimée;_
_Et que les plus beaux feux dont son cœur soit épris_
_N'oseraient l'exposer aux hontes d'un mépris._
--Act ii, sc. 1.
Know, that a princess jealous of her fame,
When she owns love, is sure of a return;
And that the noblest flame her heart can feel,
Dares not expose her to rejection's shame.
Charmion might answer: Madam, I know not what the noble flame of a
princess is, which dares not expose her to shame; and as for princesses
who never say they are in love, but when they are sure of being loved--I
always enact the part of confidante at the play: and at least twenty
princesses have confessed their noble flames to me, without being at all
sure of the matter, and especially the infanta in "The Cid."
Nay, we may go further: Cæsar--Cæsar himself--addresses Cleopatra, only
to show off double-refined wit:
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account