A Philosophical Essay on ProbabilitiesLaplace, Pierre Simon, marquis de
Philosophy
A Philosophical Essay on Probabilities
Laplace, Pierre Simon, marquis de
Probabilities
If the white and black were in equal number this probability would be
the fourth power of the probability ½ of extracting a black ball at each
drawing; it would be then 1/16. But the extraction of a white ball at
the first drawing indicates a superiority in the number of white balls
in the urn; for if one supposes in the urn three white balls and one
black the probability of extracting a white ball is ¾; it is 2/4 if one
supposes two white balls and two black; finally it is reduced to ¼ if
one supposes three black balls and one white. Following the principle of
the probability of causes drawn from events the probabilities of these
three suppositions are among themselves as the quantities ¾, 2/4, ¼;
they are consequently equal to 3/6, 2/6, ⅙. It is thus a bet of 5
against 1 that the number of black balls is inferior, or at the most
equal, to that of the white. It seems then that after the extraction of
a white ball at the first drawing, the probability of extracting
successively four black balls ought to be less than in the case of the
equality of the colors or smaller than one sixteenth. However, it is
not, and it is found by a very simple calculation that this probability
is greater than one fourteenth. Indeed it would be the fourth power of
¼, of 2/4, and of ¾ in the first, the second, and the third of the
preceding suppositions concerning the colors of the balls in the urn.
Multiplying respectively each power by the probability of the
corresponding supposition, or by 3/6, 2/6, and ⅙, the sum of the
products will be the probability of extracting successively four black
balls. One has thus for this probability 29/384, a fraction greater than
1/14. This paradox is explained by considering that the indication of
the superiority of white balls over the black ones at the first drawing
does not exclude at all the superiority of the black balls over the
white ones, a superiority which excludes the supposition of the equality
of the colors. But this superiority, though but slightly probable, ought
to render the probability of drawing successively a given number of
black balls greater than in this supposition if the number is
considerable; and one has just seen that this commences when the given
number is equal to four. Let us consider again an urn which contains
several white and black balls. Let us suppose at first that there is
only one white ball and one black. It is then an even bet that a white
ball will be extracted in one drawing. But it seems for the equality of
the bet that one who bets on extracting the white ball ought to have two
drawings if the urn contains two black and one white, three drawings if
it contains three black and one white, and so on; it is supposed that
after each drawing the extracted ball is placed again in the urn.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account