A Popular Handbook to the National Gallery, Volume I, Foreign Schools: Including by Special Permission Notes Collected from the Works of John Ruskin
History
A Popular Handbook to the National Gallery, Volume I, Foreign Schools: Including by Special Permission Notes Collected from the Works of John Ruskin
National Gallery (Great Britain); Painting -- England -- London -- Catalogs
"Now, with thus much of nature in your mind, go to Gaspard
Poussin's 'View near Albano.' It is the very subject to unite
all these effects, a sloping bank shaded with intertwined
forest. And what has Gaspard given us? A mass of smooth,
opaque, varnished brown, without one interstice, one change
of hue, or any vestige of leafy structure, in its interior,
or in those parts of it, I should say, which are intended to
represent interior; but out of it, over it rather, at regular
intervals, we have circular groups of greenish touches,
always the same in size, shape, and distance from each other,
containing so exactly the same number of touches each, that
you cannot tell one from another. There are eight or nine and
thirty of them, laid over each other like fish-scales; the
shade being most carefully made darker and darker as it recedes
from each until it comes to the edge of the next, against
which it cuts in the same sharp circular line, and then begins
to decline again, until the canvas is covered with about as
much intelligence or feeling of art as a house-painter has in
marbling a wainscot, or a weaver in repeating an ornamental
pattern. What is there in this, which the most determined
prejudice in favour of the old masters can for a moment suppose
to resemble trees? It is exactly what the most ignorant
beginner, trying to make a complete drawing, would lay down;
exactly the conception of trees which we have in the works of
our worst drawing-masters, where the shade is laid on with
the black lead and stump, and every human power exerted to
make it look like a kitchen grate well polished"[89] (_Modern
Painters_, vol. i. pt. ii. sec. vi. ch. i. §§ 16-19).
A further "untruth of vegetation" is the perpetration of the bough at
the left-hand upper corner. This is--
"a representation of an ornamental group of elephants'
tusks, with feathers tied to the end of them. Not the
wildest imagination could ever conjure up in it the remotest
resemblance to the bough of a tree. It might be the claws of
a witch, the talons of an eagle, the horns of a fiend; but it
is a full assemblage of every conceivable falsehood which can
be told respecting foliage, a piece of work so barbarous in
every way, that one glance at it ought to prove the complete
charlatanism and trickery of the whole system of the old
landscape painters" (_ibid._, § 7).
69. ST. JOHN PREACHING IN THE WILDERNESS.
_Pietro Francesco Mola_ (Eclectic-Bologna: 1612-1668).
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account