A Short History of Christianity: Second Edition, Revised, With AdditionsRobertson, J. M. (John Mackinnon)
History
A Short History of Christianity: Second Edition, Revised, With Additions
Robertson, J. M. (John Mackinnon)
Church history
These were only the most comprehensive of a multitude of Protestant
divisions. In the sixteenth century there are enumerated by
ecclesiastical historians at least eighty Protestant sects, all named
for certain special tenets, or after leaders who held themselves
apart. The general resort to the Bible had thus revived the phenomena
of the early ages of the faith; and each leading sect or church within
its own sphere sought in the papal fashion to suppress variation. The
result was a maximum of dogmatism and malice. Every sect split into
many. Thus there were some thirteen groups of Anabaptists; over thirty
separate confessions were drawn up among the main bodies; and Luther
enumerated nine varieties of doctrine on the eucharist alone. The
doctrine seldomest broached was that of mutual toleration. Between
Lutherans and Calvinists the quarrel went so far that when John
Laski, the learned Polish Calvinist, was sailing from England to the
continent on his expulsion with his adherents from England under Mary,
he was refused leave to remain at the Lutheran ports of Elsinore,
Hamburg, Lübeck, and Rostock. But as time went on the Lutherans
were divided endlessly and irreconcilably on doctrinal issues among
themselves. Melanchthon died declaring the gladness with which he
passed away from a world filled with the rabid hatreds of theologians;
and after his day matters grew worse instead of better.
From the very first, in short, the temper of Protestant propaganda, met
as it was by brutal resistance, had been one of brutal animosity. There
is indeed no more grotesque spectacle in human history than the
association of the phrase "a religion of love" with the masses of
furious controversy which constitute the bulk of Christian theological
literature in all ages of faith. Amenity has been much rarer in
religious strife than in actual warfare, where animal good humour
could at times mitigate or overlay animal hate. Fighters could meet
and banquet after a fight: theologians could not. They could feel
kindly towards those only who joined them in hating the foe. England,
with her Pecock and her Hooker, makes as good a show in this matter as
any other country; but in England the temper of the struggle between
Protestantism and Catholicism is from the first one of intense hate,
the cultured Catholic Sir Thomas More showing as little capacity for
gentleness of spirit as do the violent assailants who exasperated
him. Bale, a typical Protestant polemist, seems habitually to foam
at the mouth. War was the natural and inevitable expression of such
hatreds wherever it could come about; and when the establishment of
Protestantism left the sectarian spirit free play as between sects,
they turned to the new debate all the ferocity that had marked the old.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account