A Short History of Freethought Ancient and Modern, Volume 1 of 2: Third edition, Revised and Expanded, in two volumesRobertson, J. M. (John Mackinnon)
Religion
A Short History of Freethought Ancient and Modern, Volume 1 of 2: Third edition, Revised and Expanded, in two volumes
Robertson, J. M. (John Mackinnon)
Free thought -- History
"Besides the four hundred verses which must be excluded on the
ground that they are wanting in the Septuagint version, and were
therefore added to the text at a comparatively recent period, the
long-winded discourse of Elihu must be struck out, most [? much]
of which was composed before the book was first translated into
Greek.... In the prologue in prose ... Elihu is not once alluded
to; and in the epilogue, where all the [other] debaters are named
and censured, he ... is absolutely ignored.... Elihu's style is
toto coelo different from that of the other parts of the poem;
... while his doctrinal peculiarities, particularly his mention
of interceding angels, while they coincide with those of the New
Testament, are absolutely unknown to Job and his friends.... The
confusion introduced into the text by this insertion is bewildering
in the extreme; and yet the result is but a typical specimen of
the ... tangle which was produced by the systematic endeavour of
later and pious editors to reduce the poem to the proper level
of orthodoxy" (id. pp. 55-57). Again: "Ch. xxiv, 5-8, 10-24,
and ch. xxx, 3-7, take the place of Job's blasphemous complaint
about the unjust government of the world."
It need hardly be added here that not only the Authorized but
the Revised Version is false in the text "I know that my redeemer
liveth," etc. (xix, 25-27), that being a perversion dating from
Jerome. The probable meaning is given in Dr. Dillon's version:--
But I know that my avenger liveth;
Though it be at the end upon my dust,
My witness will avenge these things,
And a curse alight upon mine enemies.
The original expressed a complete disbelief in a future life
(ch. xiv). Compare Dr. Dillon's rhythmic version of the restored
text.
What marks off the book of Job from all other Hebrew literature
is its dramatic and reflective handling of the ethical problem of
theism, which the prophets either evade or dismiss by declamation
against Jewish sins. Not that it is solved in Job, where the rôle of
Satan is an inconclusive resort to the Persian dualistic solution,
and where the deity is finally made to answer Job's freethinking
by sheer literary thunder, much less ratiocinative though far more
artistic than the theistic speeches of the friends. But at least the
writer or writers of Job's speeches consciously grasped the issue;
and the writer of the epilogue evidently felt that the least Yahweh
could do was to compensate a man whom he had allowed to be wantonly
persecuted. The various efforts of ancient thought to solve the same
problem will be found to constitute the motive power in many later
heterodox systems, theistic and atheistic.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account