A Short History of Freethought Ancient and Modern, Volume 1 of 2: Third edition, Revised and Expanded, in two volumesRobertson, J. M. (John Mackinnon)
Religion
A Short History of Freethought Ancient and Modern, Volume 1 of 2: Third edition, Revised and Expanded, in two volumes
Robertson, J. M. (John Mackinnon)
Free thought -- History
As to his practical failure see the story of his and his pupils'
attempts at Syracuse (Grote, History, ix, 37-123). The younger
Dionysios, whom they had vainly attempted to make a model ruler,
seems to have been an audacious unbeliever to the extent of
plundering the temple of Persephone at Lokris, one of Jupiter in
the Peloponnesos, and one of Æsculapius at Epidaurus. Clement of
Alexandria (Protrept. c. 4) states that he plundered "the statue
of Jupiter in Sicily." Cicero (De nat. Deorum, iii, 33, 34) and
Valerius Maximus (i, 1) tell the story of the elder Dionysios;
but of him it cannot be true. In his day the plunder of the
temples of Dêmêtêr and Persephone in Sicily by the Carthaginians
was counted a deadly sin. See Freeman, History of Sicily, iv,
125-47, and Story of Sicily, pp. 176-80. In Cicero's dialogue it
is noted that after all his impieties Dionysios [the elder, of
whom the stories are mistakenly told] died in his bed. Athenæus,
however, citing the biographer Klearchos, tells that the younger
Dionysios, after being reduced to the rôle of a begging priest
of Kybelê, ended his life very miserably (xii, 60).
Nonetheless, the prescription of intolerance in the Laws [674] classes
Plato finally on the side of fanaticism, and, indeed, ranks him with
the most sinister figures on that side, since his earlier writing
shows that he would be willing to punish men alike for repeating
stories which they believed, and for rejecting what he knew to be
untruths. [675] By his own late doctrine he vindicated the slayers of
his own friend. His psychology is as strange as that of Aristophanes,
but strange with a difference. He seems to have practised "the will
to believe" till he grew to be a fanatic on the plane of the most
ignorant of orthodox Athenians; and after all that science had done
to enlighten men on that natural order the misconceiving of which had
been the foundation of their creeds, he inveighs furiously in his old
age against the impiety of those who dared to doubt that the sun and
moon and stars were deities, as every nurse taught her charges. [676]
And when all is said, his Gods satisfy no need of the intelligence;
for he insists that they only partially rule the world, sending the few
good things, but not the many evil [677]--save insofar as evil may be
a beneficent penalty and discipline. At the same time, while advising
the imprisonment or execution of heretics who did not believe in the
Gods, Plato regarded with even greater detestation the man who taught
that they could be persuaded or propitiated by individual prayer and
sacrifice. [678] Thus he would have struck alike at the freethinking
few and at the multitude who held by the general religious beliefs of
Greece, dealing damnation on all save his own clique, in a way that
would have made Torquemada blench. [679] In the face of such teaching
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account