A system of practical medicine. By American authors. Vol. 5 : $b Diseases of the nervous system
Science
A system of practical medicine. By American authors. Vol. 5 : $b Diseases of the nervous system
Medicine -- Practice
Insanity may be of congenital origin or slowly developed from early
childhood, but usually it indicates a change caused by disease, so
that the person alleged to be insane must, as a rule, be compared with
himself at some previous time, and not with some ideal standard of
mental health which does not exist. Indeed, if we could measure nicely
no two of us could be fairly held to precisely the same degree of
accountability. The knowledge of right and wrong is not a fair
criterion, as many insane men possess that knowledge well enough in
the abstract. The ability to distinguish right from wrong in the
particular act is possessed by some insane persons whose will and
power of self-control have become so limited by disease that they
cannot avoid what they know to be crime. Delusion overpowering the
mind is sufficient evidence of irresponsibility, but all delusions are
by no means so powerful that they cannot be resisted, and many must be
classed as simply false beliefs or mistaken views which could be, and
should be, controlled. In case, therefore, of alleged delusions not
manifestly insane further evidence of insanity is required, and the
way in which a man believes or does anything may be more of an
indication as to the soundness or unsoundness of his mind than what he
believes or does. A crime committed under the influence of maniacal
delirium, acute delirious mania, epileptic furor, uncontrollable
impulse, alcoholic insanity, or hysterical mental disease will usually
explain itself, while a demented insane person is so characteristic an
object that his crime cannot well be mistaken for that of a
responsible agent.
The different conditions of mind grouped under the general terms moral
insanity, affective insanity, and impulsive insanity are still the
bugbear of jurists, and there is a wide difference of opinion as to
the degree of accountability for actions performed under the influence
of moral perversion with only slight intellectual impairment; but the
degree to which the individual deviates from the path of the law may
depend more upon his training and surroundings than upon his
disease—points which must always be considered in establishing a
definition of insanity in obscure cases. Of two persons whose
circumstances in life, in connection with a certain amount of disease,
have produced as nearly as possible identical morbid mental states, it
now and then happens that the necessary surroundings of the one steady
and support him, while the associations and conditions of life throw
the other still more off his balance. The one is able to sustain the
ordinary relations with the world, the other not.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account