A Treatise on the Art of Midwifery: Setting Forth Various Abuses Therein, Especially as to the Practice With Instruments: the Whole Serving to Put All Rational Inquirers in a Fair Way of Very Safely Forming Their Own Judgement Upon the Question; Which It Is Best to Employ, in Cases of Pregnancy and Lying-in, a Man-midwife; Or, a MidwifeNihell, Elizabeth
History
A Treatise on the Art of Midwifery: Setting Forth Various Abuses Therein, Especially as to the Practice With Instruments: the Whole Serving to Put All Rational Inquirers in a Fair Way of Very Safely Forming Their Own Judgement Upon the Question; Which It Is Best to Employ, in Cases of Pregnancy and Lying-in, a Man-midwife; Or, a Midwife
Nihell, Elizabeth
Midwifery -- Early works to 1800; Obstetrics -- Early works to 1800
expressly says, “that a sudden unexpected death of his patient was one
of those FATALITIES, that not all the human prudence can prevent.”
BUT that I may not here incur the least charge of unfairness, as if I
meant by this quotation any thing so absurd or unjust, as that in the
labors of pregnant women, as well as in other diseases unconnected with
them, there may not sometimes happen accidents impossible to be
foreseen, as well under the care of the best physician, called in by the
very best midwife, as under the most ignorant assuming man-midwife, I
shall here introduce another quotation from the same _Levret_, that will
especially shew the ladies, and all parties concerned, to what an
imaginary safety, so much, and even the very point sought for, is
sacrificed as is sacrificed, in preferring the men-practitioners to the
midwives. [8] “M. de la Motte says, that for the fifth time he laid the
wife of a glover of Valogne, the 16th of March, 1704; that the woman was
but an hour in her labor-pains, and that he delivered her with all the
facility imaginable; that he left her upon the couch till he had given
her some broth, after which he recommended her to the care of the nurse,
and went _where his business called him_. He adds, that he had time but
just to bleed two persons in the neighbourhood, before he was fetched
away in haste to see the patient he had just laid, whom he found _dead_
upon the bed. The cause of this _death_ was instantly manifest to him
from the stream of _blood_, which ran about the floor, and even
penetrated to the apartment beneath, after soaking through the bed
itself, in which there remained clots of blood of an extraordinary size.
“THIS author adds, in the reflexions at the end of this observation,
that this delivery had been both more easy and more expeditious than any
this woman had precedently had: and he notes, that these _melancholic
accidents_ are not _without example_, since such ladies as the princess
of ... and madam la Presidente de —— with _numbers_ of _others_, have,
on the like occasion, undergone the same _fate_, as her he here treats
of. These are, according to him, _proofs_ that all human science and
dexterity _often_ cannot prevent the _like misfortunes_, since these
_great ladies_ had been lain by the most _celebrated men-midwives_.”
NOW I might here, without much probability of being contradicted, aver,
that where such accidents, said to happen so _frequently_ and
inevitably, should happen under the hands of midwives, there would be
but one voice among the men-practitioners and their credulous adherents,
to impute them to the ignorance and malpractice of the women. The plea
of _occult causes_ would be hooted at in them, tho’ receivable, it
seems, from the men.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account