A Whim, and Its Consequences: Collection of British Authors Vol. CXIVJames, G. P. R. (George Payne Rainsford)
General
A Whim, and Its Consequences: Collection of British Authors Vol. CXIV
James, G. P. R. (George Payne Rainsford)
Fiction
"I know not how it is, but none of these Italian poets interest me
much--perhaps the most, that mad-cap Ariosto. There is a reckless
vigour about him which none of the rest possesses; and their
prettinesses tire. Tasso is certainly very sweet and very graceful,
but seldom powerful; and Dante, dark, terrible, and stern, wants the
relief of beauty. His Inferno is certainly a grand poem, the
personification of thousand hates and vengeances; but the Paradise is
a poor affair.
"It is very strange how much more difficult men find it to imagine and
to paint perfect happiness than exquisite torture. Perhaps it is
because in this life we are much more familiar with pain than
pleasure. Pain and grief are to human beings, positive; our greatest
happiness here below rarely more than negative--at all events, never
unmixed. But in none of the Italians do we find the grand march, the
sustained majesty of the Greeks and the Romans. I cannot help thinking
that Boccaccio had more poetry in his nature than most of his
brethren; and there are some fine passages in his great poem,
notwithstanding its many wants. Many of his novels, too, are full of
poetry. But, after all, ten lines of Homer are worth all the Italian
poetry that ever was written. Alfieri seems to have felt this
inferiority of the poets of Italy to the ancients, even too much; and
the effect has been a stiffness in his writings, produced by aiming at
dignity in a language which is not dignified. When the thought itself
is grand, its grandeur can only be preserved in so weak a tongue by
clothing it in the very simplest words. Dante was not alone aware of
this, but was impelled to that course by his own sharp character. He
never strove to embellish by mere words, though sometimes, as if to
impress the idea upon the reader's mind, he reiterates it in another
form, venturing upon pleonasm as a means of force, in which he was
probably mistaken; at least, the effect upon my mind is always
disagreeable. It would be better if the verses were spoken. I cannot
but think--though perhaps it is national partiality--that the poets of
England are superior to any that have ever lived since the fall of the
Roman empire. The French have no poetry. The Germans have two or three
great poets; but their literature may be considered as yet in its
infancy. The Spaniards have some beautiful poems, it is true; but in
all of them are blemishes which overbalance the perfections. In the
English tongue there has been excellent poetry enough written in every
different style and manner, to supply the whole world. A crowd of our
poets are unknown even to ourselves; and many of the very best are
imperfectly known, and that but to a few. The sonnet, indeed, attained
its highest point with Petrarch; and yet how beautiful are some of Sir
Philip Sidney's!--for instance, the one beginning--
'No more, my dear, no more these councils try,
Oh give my passions leave to run their race.'
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account