A Whim, and Its Consequences: Collection of British Authors Vol. CXIVJames, G. P. R. (George Payne Rainsford)
General
A Whim, and Its Consequences: Collection of British Authors Vol. CXIV
James, G. P. R. (George Payne Rainsford)
Fiction
"I must beg the interference of the court in protection of my client,"
said the prisoner's counsel, in a firm and stern tone; "it is contrary
to all practice, and, I must add, contrary to all justice, to allude
to imaginary circumstances as facts when there is no intention of
proving them, thereby producing an impression upon the minds of the
jury most detrimental to a prisoner, without giving the prisoner's
counsel a fair opportunity of removing it. Were it not a most
dangerous precedent, I should say that I am very glad such a course
has been pursued by my learned friend, as, in this case, I am in a
condition to rebut his insinuations as well as to disprove his facts;
but, reverencing law and justice, and seeing great inconvenience
likely to occur hereafter from such a practice, I must most solemnly
claim the protection of the court for my client."
"The jury will rely only upon evidence," said the judge; "the
assertions or insinuations of counsel, unsupported by evidence, are
mere wind. The course of alluding even to any circumstance not
intended to be proved, I must say, is very mischievous; but I dare say
it was in the brief."
"I bow to the decision of the court," said the leader for the Crown;
"but I can assure my learned friend, that I intended to produce no
impression upon the minds of the jury but a just one; and, without at
all recurring to the past, I am perfectly prepared to show by evidence
that at the time the murder was committed, the prisoner at the bar and
the unfortunate Mr. Roberts were engaged in a very sharp dispute about
some property left to the former. I have said, gentlemen of the jury,"
he continued, with perfect tranquillity and satisfaction, "that it
would be irrelevant to inquire what could induce a gentleman of the
prisoner's rank and pretensions to accept the humble post of gardener
in the family of Mr. Tracy. However, the fact that he did so will be
established, and in that situation he inhabited a cottage (number 9 in
the plan) close to the hedge bordering the Lady's Walk, and was
entrusted with a key of the small gate into the grounds (at number
10.) It will be in evidence, gentlemen, that after having been absent
for about a month, by Mr. Tracy's permission, during which he had
resumed his station, mingled with his own rank of society in London,
and fought a duel with Viscount Overton, in which the latter was
desperately wounded, the prisoner returned to his cottage at
Northferry on the afternoon of the fifth of February, the day of the
murder, and almost immediately went out again. It will be shown to
you, that the sun was then setting, or had already set, and that he
entered the gardens, and took his way towards the very spot where the
crime was committed, having in his hand the identical hoe (or one
precisely similar) which was afterwards found by the dead body. This
will be proved by two witnesses, whose veracity will not, I presume,
be impeached. You will soon have it in evidence, that he did not
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account