A Whim, and Its Consequences: Collection of British Authors Vol. CXIVJames, G. P. R. (George Payne Rainsford)
General
A Whim, and Its Consequences: Collection of British Authors Vol. CXIV
James, G. P. R. (George Payne Rainsford)
Fiction
The learned gentleman paused, and, from under his bushy eyebrows,
turned a glance towards the face of the leader for the defence. What
he saw there he did not exactly understand; for there was a very
slight smile on the great barrister's lip; but that smile had
something of triumph in it. He knew not if the smile was sincere, or
whether it was not assumed to cover mortification; but yet, it was
evidently kept down rather than displayed, and in this state of doubt
he might not have called the boy, perhaps, had it been possible to
avoid it. The passing of these considerations through his mind did not
arrest his eloquence for more than a moment, and he went on as
follows:--
"I have now, gentlemen of the jury, given you a brief outline of the
case against the prisoner, as I believe it will be fully proved by
evidence; and I do not think, if such be the case, and if the
respectability of the witnesses is unimpeached and their testimony be
not shaken by cross-examination, that you can come to any other
conclusion than that which, I grieve to say, I myself have arrived at.
You will hear what they have to say, you will judge from their words,
and even the manner in which their evidence is given, what credence
they deserve. God forbid that you should attach more to their evidence
against the prisoner than to any testimony which can be fairly adduced
in his favour. What course of defence my learned friend may adopt I
cannot divine, but mere testimonials of character, learning, high
qualities, and previous integrity cannot avail here. Nor must rank and
station be taken for one moment into consideration. A prisoner at the
bar of justice stands stripped of all adventitious advantages. He is
there as before the throne of Heaven, only in the common character of
man. If he be of high rank and good education, it is no reason for
pre-supposing innocence or extenuating guilt. Quite on the contrary.
Crimes of the most serious magnitude have been proved against persons
greatly elevated in station. Peers of England have suffered on the
scaffold for deliberate murder; and the advantages of rank and
education, in the immunity which they give from ordinary temptation,
only serve to aggravate the offence. Nor can a previous upright,
honourable, and even peaceful life, if it could here be proved, weigh
much to neutralize distinct evidence. We have too many instances,
gentlemen, of men, the great bulk of whose life has been high, holy,
and innocent, yielding to some strong temptation, and committing acts
which on cooler reflection they have often shuddered at. Need I cite
the case of the unfortunate Dr. Dodd? You must look upon the prisoner
merely as a man; you must weigh well every tittle of the evidence
against him. You will find that, as in almost all cases of murder,
that evidence is purely circumstantial; no man but a madman commits
such a crime when the eyes of any but accomplices are upon him. But
you have all too much good sense and experience not to know that a
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account